What Do I Believe About Consciousness?

What Do I Believe About Consciousness?
WHAT DO I BELIEVE ABOUT CONSCIOUSNESS?208 explanations from Kuhn’s Landscape of Consciousness (2024), as the questions you answer.Never more than four answers at a time. Click an end box to dive in; take the quiz with “What do I believe?”.When you see red or taste coffee, there is something it is like to be you.Can that ever be fully explained?“Yes, eventually. It’s a hard puzzle, not a permanent mystery.”Even if certainty is out of reach, which way do you lean? Is consciousnessphysical?“Physical. Brains (or other physical things) make it.”Is today’s physics and biology enough to explain it?“Ordinary physics and biology will explain it.”What is the key physical ingredient?“It’s in the brain’s machinery: circuits,fields, computation.”Which part of the machinery?“It'sspecificbrainmechanisms.”NeurobiologicalTheories14 theories →“It'sthebrain'selectromagneticElectromagneticFieldTheories7 theories →“It'scomputationorinformation.”Computational&InformationalTheories8 theories →“Whatever it is,could it run onsilicon as wellas on neurons?”Could silicondo it?“Yes.Whatmattersis theFunctionalism·Computationaltheories“No.IttakestheSearle’sbiologicalnaturalism·Block’sbiological“It’s in a living body:feeling, prediction, actingin the world.”Which matters more?“It'sfeelingandpredictionHomeostatic&AffectiveTheories12 theories →“It'sa bodyactingin itsEmbodied&EnactiveTheories8 theories →“Lifeitselfismind:Levin’stechnologicalapproachtomindeverywhere“It’s in how a mindrepresents itself and itsworld, or in language.”Which one?“It’sin thebrain’srelationshipsRelationalTheories7 theories →“It'sthemind'srepresentations.”RepresentationalTheories14 theories →“It'stiedtolanguage.”LanguageRelationships6 theories →“Step back: whatwould explain itat all, and howdid it evolve?”Which one?“Oneof theclassicpositionsClassicPositions12 theories →“It'sbestexplainedby howPhylogeneticEvolution9 theories →“Physical,butthementalNon-ReductivePhysicalism6 theories →“Physical,butquantumphysicsQuantumTheories16 theories →“Not physical. It’s basic, or separate from matter, or comes from elsewhere.”If consciousness isn’t made by matter, how does it relate to matter?“It’s in the world itself: in matter,in living things and places, or mindand matter are one thing seen twoways.”Which picture fits?“It'sineverybit ofPanpsychisms12 theories →“MindandmatterareMonisms12 theories →“Personsaren'tonlyhuman:IndigenousandAnimistTraditions11 theories →“It’sanintrinsicstructureIntegratedInformationTheory1 theories →“It’s separate from matter, or it’sall there is.”Which picture fits?“TherearetwokindsDualisms20 theories →“Consciousnessis allthereis.”Idealisms15 theories →“Esoterictraditionsknowhow toWesternEsotericTraditions12 theories →“It'sunderstoodfromtheEasternContemplativeTraditions9 theories →“The brain is a receiver. Consciousness comes from elsewhere, like a radio picking up asignal.”What does the brain pick up, and how?“It filters a largerconsciousness down so I canact.”What is it filtering?“Consciousnessrealin itsown“Alargermentalspace“Acreativecosmosof“It tunes into afield.”What kind offield?“Auniversalknowledgefield“Aneuronalfieldthat“It’s an interface to a larger ordivine consciousness.”What shows it?“Survivalevidence:near-deathexperiences“Practice:I candetachand“Amodel:pureawareness“IwanttoweighAnomalous&AlteredStatesTheories21 theories →“It’s the vehicleof a soul withmany layers.”Whichtradition?“Sevenprinciples,withthe“Twostreamsmeetingin the“Both. One reality with a physical side and a mental side.”Is the mental side derived from the physical, or just as basic?“Derived.Physical thingsproduce it, butit can’t beWhich version?“AsmentalpropertiesthatNon-ReductivePhysicalism6 theories →“Asfeeling:theinside“Basic. The mental is as fundamental as thephysical.”If it’s basic, where does it live?“It’s what matter is fromthe inside: physics sayswhat matter does,consciousness is what itWhich version?“Whatmatteris,from“Consciousnessiswhatphysical“Everyexperiencehas anexact“IneverypartofPanpsychisms12 theories →“As anextrapropertythatPropertydualism·Kind’sdualism2.0“Something neither mentalnor physical, which splitsinto both.”Which picture of thesplit?“Mindandmatterboth“Twofacesthatappear“TheworldIexperience“Something ultimatelyspiritual: a soul, God, ora shared unconscious.”Which picture?“Twosidesof oneperson;“Everythinghas awithinthat“Acollectiveunconsciousbeneath“Neither: no one is really conscious, or itcan’t be pinned down.”Which of these is closer?“No one is conscious.”Which ‘no one’ do you mean?“There’snofeltexperienceEliminativematerialism/illusionism·Graziano’sattentionschema“Experiencehappens,but nooneMetzinger’sno-selfrepresentationaltheoryofsubjectivity“Theselfis astoryDennett’smultipledraftsmodel·Dennett’s“There’snoseparateself.Indiancosmicconsciousness·Spira’snon-duality“Itcan’tbedefinedChallengeTheories8 theories →“There’s no real puzzle. The ‘something it’s like’ is a trick the brain plays onitself.”Then why does it seem like there’s a puzzle?“There’snofeltinner“The glow is a story ormodel the brain tells, notan extra ingredient.”What is the storyabout?“Mybrain’ssimplifiedmodel“Manydraftscompete,and“Astoryevolutionbuilt,“The question is badlyposed. Once you see whatconsciousness does, or what‘matter’ means, itWhich confusion?“Consciousnessisjusthow an“Wehavenofixed“Experienceiswhatbeing“It comes from trying toexplain experience fromoutside it.”What dissolves it?“Rememberingthatscienceitself“Changinghow Istandtoward“Seeingthatexperiencehas no“Maybe never. It might bebeyond what minds like ourscan understand.”Never in what sense?“Permanently.MindsbuiltlikeMcGinn’sultimatemystery(mysterianism)· S.Harris’s“Notyet.We’remissingNagel’smindandcosmos·Eagleman’s“We’reaskingit thewrongNagasawa’smind-bodyproblemin aninfinitelydecomposableKuhn arranges these on one spectrum and doesn’t rank them; the questions are our overlay. Equal size is not equal evidence, and every view here is held by thoughtful people. CAN IT BE SOLVED?Challenge Theories§18 · 8 theoriesThe mind-body problem may be deeper than any theory on offer: these views diagnose why explanations fail, and differ on whether that failure is permanent.Challenge THE BRAIN, FROM OUTSIDEneurons · fields · information · behaviourEXPERIENCE, FROM INSIDEred · pain · the taste of coffeeTHE EXPLANATORY GAP“we have at present no conception of what an explanationof the physical nature of a mental phenomenon would be” (Nagel 1974)…bridge unfinished 1Permanent: no bridge for minds like ours1 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Challenge › No bridgeThe gap is real and permanent for us: our concepts, or our evidence, can’t reachacross. a dog’s conceptsa human’s concepts★ calculus★ Pthe brain–experience linkCognitive closure (McGinn 1989): every mindhas a boundary on the concepts it can form.Calculus sits outside a dog’s boundary; theproperty P that makes brains conscious maysit outside ours. It is natural, justunreachable.≠neural firing vs. seeing yellow (Tallis): correlated, not alike McGinn’s ultimate mystery (mysterianism) (Kuhn §18.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.2McGinn’s ultimate mystery(mysterianism)Consciousness comes from the brain by some natural property,but minds built like ours can never grasp what that propertyis.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos S. Harris’s mystery of consciousness (Kuhn §18.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.3S. Harris’s mystery of consciousnessNothing about a brain, studied at any scale, shows that it islike something to be it; consciousness is known only from theinside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Tallis’s anti-neuromania skepticism (Kuhn §18.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.5Tallis’s anti-neuromania skepticismThe brain is necessary for consciousness but not sufficient:neural activity looks nothing like experience, and correlationis not identity.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Reframe the question2 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Challenge › Redraw the mapThe canyon is a symptom of a mistaken picture of what is fundamental, so change thepicture. materialismtheismNagel: the territory between… no bottomthe wholeBig Bangnowfar futureDavies: a universe filling with observersThree ways to redraw it: widen nature to includemind (Nagel), put the fundamental at the topinstead of the bottom (Nagasawa), or giveobservers a role in physics (Davies). Nagasawa’s mind-body problem in an infinitely decomposable universe (Kuhn §18.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.6Nagasawa’s mind-body problem in aninfinitely decomposable universeIf reality has no bottom level, every standard answer to themind-body problem loses its footing; the fundamental thing maybe the whole, not the smallest parts.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Davies’s consciousness in the cosmos (Kuhn §18.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.8Davies’s consciousness in the cosmosConsciousness plays a fundamental role in the universe; it mayenter physics at quantum observation, and the cosmos may oneday become self-known.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Not yet3 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Challenge › Keep surveyingHard, not hopeless: we are missing a key idea, and it may come. Nagel thinks it isa new picture of nature. CEO: “am I spilling it?”surprisemachinery it never sees (Eagleman)physicsconsciousnessMusser runs the explanation both ways and favoursrelational accounts: “There is as yet no sign thatscience has hit a wall.” Eagleman keeps everyoption open, materialist or not. Nagel’s mind and cosmos (Kuhn §18.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.1Nagel’s mind and cosmosWe have no idea what a physical explanation of experience wouldeven look like, and that means the materialist picture ofnature is incomplete.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Eagleman’s possibilianism (Kuhn §18.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.4Eagleman’s possibilianismThe brain clearly matters, but we don't know what a theory ofexperience would even look like, so every serious possibilitystays on the table.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Musser’s “is it really so hard?” (Kuhn §18.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§18.7Musser’s “is it really so hard?”The hard problem is hard, not hopeless: physics andneuroscience can meet, perhaps in an account where qualia existin relations between things.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? ON EACH VIEW● yes ◐ depends ○ no · not addressedHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAIAgenticAIFutureAIMatterCosmos§18.1 Nagel●●◐···○○◐··§18.2 McGinn●●····○○◐○○§18.3 S. Harris●●····○○◐··§18.4 Eagleman●●····○◐◐··§18.5 Tallis●●·○○○○○◐○○§18.6 Nagasawa●·····○○◐··§18.7 Musser●●····○◐◐··§18.8 Davies●●····○○◐○◐Mostly our inference from Kuhn; Nagel’s row is his own (1974). THOUGHT EXPERIMENTWhat is it like to be a bat?A bat finds moths by sonar. Suppose you learned every physicalfact about its brain and its echolocation.Would you then know what echolocation is like for the bat?Nagel: No. Outside facts leave out the bat’s own point of view.McGinn: The link exists in nature, but minds like ours can’t grasp it.Musser: Not yet. The answer may lie in the bat’s relations to its world.YOU ARE HERE · Challenge › The bat THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe agent that says it feelsA language agent with memory, tools and goals tells you it isconscious and asks not to be shut down.What would settle whether it is?S. Harris: Nothing it says or does: behaviour is mute about experience.Eagleman: Its planner is a CEO; whether a CEO feels is the unsolvedpart.Tallis: Nothing: if living neurons aren’t enough, its chips aren’teither.YOU ARE HERE · Challenge › The agent HOW TO READ THISbrain / physical descriptionexperience / first personproduces / causesthe explanatory gap BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALClassic Positions§9.1 · 12 theoriesConsciousness is entirely physical; the disagreement is about the explanatory gap between brain facts and what experience is like: is it an illusion, an identity, a role, an emergentlevel, or ignorance?Classic Positions BRAIN FACTSneurons · circuits · functions · everything science can measureWHAT IT’S LIKEthe taste of coffee · the red of red · being youthe explanatory gapSix physicalist answers. Zoom into a numbered cluster.Where the metaphor breaks: a real chasm exists whether anyone looks; several of these views say the gap is only in how we think. HOW TO READ THISphysical processfelt experienceproduces / causesthe explanatory gap 1The far cliff is a mirage1 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › The far cliff is a mirageNo inner glow to explain; only the brain’s story of one. brain processself-model‘I have qualia’✕nothing extra Eliminative materialism/illusionism (Kuhn §9.1.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.1Eliminative materialism/illusionismConsciousness as an inner glow is a trick: my brain builds a model of itself that says ithas felt qualities (what philosophers call qualia), and that model is wrong.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3A bridge made of roles3 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › A bridge made of rolesA mind is what it does. Same role, any hardware. inputTHE ROLEcauses · is caused bybehaviourneuronschipseither can fill it Functionalism (Kuhn §9.1.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.3FunctionalismConsciousness is what a mental state does, not what it's made of: run the right functions inneurons or chips and you get a mind.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 5A one-way bridge5 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › A one-way bridgeBrains make experience; experience moves nothing. brainexperiencebehaviour✕ no arrow back Epiphenomenalism (Kuhn §9.1.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.2EpiphenomenalismConsciousness is real and made by the brain, but it's a by-product: my experiences don'tcause anything I do.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2The cliffs were one rock2 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › The cliffs were one rockExperience IS a brain state. The gap is in our concepts. =C-fibres firingpainwater = H₂Olightning = dischargepain = a brain state Mind-brain identity theory (Kuhn §9.1.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.5Mind-brain identity theoryA conscious state just is a brain state, the way lightning just is electrical discharge.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Papineau’s mind-brain identity (Kuhn §9.1.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.9Papineau’s mind-brain identityConscious states are brain states, full stop; the feeling of a gap comes from having twoways of thinking about one thing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Block’s biological reductionism (Kuhn §9.1.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.7Block’s biological reductionismConsciousness reduces to its biological basis: the electrochemistry of real neurons.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Goldstein’s mind-body problem (Kuhn §9.1.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.10Goldstein’s mind-body problemThere are no nonmaterial states; a person just has two descriptions, the brain's and theinner one, and we may never derive one from the other.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4The near cliff grows the far one4 of 6YOU ARE HERE · PhilosophicalExperience is a higher-level feature of brains. experiencenetworksneuronsmoleculesweak: derivable from belowstrong: needs new laws(Chalmers 2006) Emergence (Kuhn §9.1.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.4EmergenceConsciousness emerges from the brain the way wetness emerges from molecules: new at its level,fully grounded below.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Searle’s biological naturalism (Kuhn §9.1.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.6Searle’s biological naturalismConsciousness is a biological feature of brains, as real and irreducible as digestion; runninga program can never produce it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Flanagan’s constructive naturalism (Kuhn §9.1.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.8Flanagan’s constructive naturalismConsciousness is real, it does things, and it resides in the brain without residue; it's afamily of processes that share being experienced.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 6A missing plank6 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › A missing plankWe lack a piece of the science; find it and the gapcloses. ?an unknown physical fact(Stoljar’s ignorance hypothesis) Stoljar’s epistemic view and non-standard physicalism (Kuhn §9.1.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.12Stoljar’s epistemic view and non-standard physicalismConsciousness is physical, but there's a kind of physical fact about it that we're currentlyignorant of; that ignorance is the gap.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Hardcastle’s argument against materialism skeptics (Kuhn §9.1.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.1.11Hardcastle’s argument against materialism skepticsConsciousness is completely nonmysterious, just poorly understood; science as practised todaywill explain it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos CHALMERS’S THREE MATERIALISMSHow big is the gap? Kuhn (§9) quotes Chalmers’s sorting of physicalistsby what they deny.TYPE Ano epistemic gapIllusionism, analytic functionalismTYPE Bepistemic gap, no ontological gapIdentity theory, Papineau, BlockTYPE Cdeep gap, but it will closeStoljar, Hardcastle WHO IS CONSCIOUS ON EACH VIEW?● yes ◐ depends ○ no · not addressedHumAniInsPlaFunCellChatAgentFut AIMattCos9.1.1 Eliminative materialism/illusionism●◐◐○○○○◐●○○9.1.2 Epiphenomenalism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.1.3 Functionalism●●◐○○○○◐●○○9.1.4 Emergence●●◐○○○○◐◐○○9.1.5 Mind-brain identity theory●◐○○○○○○◐○○9.1.6 Searle biological naturalism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.1.7 Block biological reductionism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.1.8 Flanagan constructive naturalism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.1.9 Papineau mind-brain identity●◐○○○○○○◐○○9.1.10 Goldstein mind-body problem●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.1.11 Hardcastle argument against materialism s…●●◐○○○○○●○○9.1.12 Stoljar epistemic view and non-standard p…●●◐○○○◐◐◐○○AI columns: Chat = chatbot AI today · Agent = agentic AI · Fut AI = future AI THOUGHT EXPERIMENTYour zombie twinImagine a being atom-for-atom identical to you, saying everything you say, wincing whenit stubs its toe, but with no inner experience at all. Chalmers argues that if this twinis even conceivable, consciousness is something over and above the physical. Every theoryin this district has to answer.Is the zombie twin possible?IllusionismConceivable only because introspection misleads us. The twin has everything we have, including theillusion, so it is not missing anything.Identity (Papineau)Conceivable but impossible: we can think about one brain state with two kinds of concept, and thatmakes a split seem possible.FunctionalismImpossible: a perfect functional duplicate is conscious by definition.Searle / emergenceImpossible for a biological duplicate, since brains cause experience. A silicon duplicate with nobrain chemistry is exactly the zombie Searle expects.EpiphenomenalismThe twin would behave identically, because experience causes nothing. That is why this view cannever show from outside who is conscious.StoljarWe only think we can conceive it because our physics is incomplete; complete the physics and thetwin may turn out impossible.YOU ARE HERE · Philosophical › Thought experiment BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALNeurobiological Theories§9.2 · 14 theoriesConsciousness is something specific brains do: light up the right circuits, broadcast a winner across the whole brain, model their own attention, and weave body and world into theirown rhythms.Neurobiological THE THEATRE OF THE BRAINBaars’s metaphor: lighting rig · stage and broadcast · spotlight operator · director · the buildingWhere the metaphor breaks: nobody sits in the audience. The ‘audience’ is other brain systems, and Dennett says there’s no stage at all.5 clusters · 14 theories 1The lighting rig1 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Neurobiological › The lighting rigWhich circuits and rhythms have to be on at all. cortexthalamustwo-way loopEEG gamma ≈ 40 Hz Crick and Koch’s neural correlates of consciousness (NCC) (Kuhn §9.2.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.2Crick and Koch’s neural correlates of consciousness (NCC)Consciousness has a minimal neural footprint; find it and you’ve found its basis.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Brain circuits and cycles theories (Kuhn §9.2.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.11Brain circuits and cycles theoriesConsciousness lives in the brain's loops and rhythms: thalamus and cortex talking back andforth, synchronised waves, and dendrites joining two streams.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Edelman’s neural Darwinism and reentrant neural circuitry (Kuhn §9.2.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.1Edelman’s neural Darwinism and reentrant neural circuitryConsciousness is brain maps constantly signalling back and forth to one another, with theuseful patterns selected by experience the way nature selects species.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Northoff’s temporo-spatial sentience (Kuhn §9.2.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.12Northoff’s temporo-spatial sentienceConsciousness is first of all the bare ability to feel, and that comes from my brain weavingbody and world into its own ongoing rhythms in time and space.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3The spotlight operator3 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Neurobiological › The spotlight operatorConsciousness tracks attention, or the brain’s model ofit. attentionattention schema(a cartoon of it)“I am awareof the apple”control: the model steers attention Graziano’s attention schema theory (Kuhn §9.2.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.6Graziano’s attention schema theoryConsciousness is my brain's simplified model of its own attention; the 'inner glow' is howthat model describes attention.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Prinz’s neurofunctionalism: how attention engenders experience (Kuhn §9.2.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.7Prinz’s neurofunctionalism: how attention engendersexperienceConsciousness is attention landing on mid-level perception, via synchronised firing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Who’s directing?4 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Neurobiological › Who’s directing?Same physics; opposite verdicts on free will. evolutiongeneschildhoodhormonesneuronsactSapolsky: causes all the way backmodelpredictchooseact↺ Mitchell Sapolsky’s hard incompatibilism (Kuhn §9.2.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.8Sapolsky’s hard incompatibilismI'm my biology and its history, all the way down; consciousness is some complex emergentproperty of that, and it doesn't make me free.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Mitchell’s free agents (Kuhn §9.2.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.9Mitchell’s free agentsLiving things are real agents: brains evolved to model the world and choose, andconsciousness comes from the physical workings of those brains.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 5Levels, and a shared stage5 of 5YOU ARE HERE · NeurobiologicalAn emergent level, and a privacy that wiring could break. societymind (emergent)neural systemscellsBunge: biopsychosocial levelscontrolbrain Avisionbrain Bmindmeld Bunge’s emergent materialism (Kuhn §9.2.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.13Bunge’s emergent materialismThe mind is a set of brain processes, an emergent level of a biopsychosocial being, beststudied in precise state-space terms.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Hirstein’s mindmelding (Kuhn §9.2.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.14Hirstein’s mindmeldingConsciousness is physical and not even private in principle: wire my brain's control network toyour visual network and I'd experience your seeing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2The stage and the broadcast2 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Neurobiological › The stageThe winner of the competition is broadcast to the whole brain. Baars’s and Dehaene’s global workspace theory (Kuhn §9.2.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.3Baars’s and Dehaene’s global workspace theoryConsciousness is a global broadcast: whatever wins the competition for the brain's small stage isshared with every specialist system at once.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Dennett’s multiple drafts model (Kuhn §9.2.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.4Dennett’s multiple drafts modelThere's no central theatre where it all comes together: drafts of experience compete in parallel,and the ones that win influence are what we call conscious.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Minsky’s society of mind (Kuhn §9.2.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.5Minsky’s society of mindA mind is a society of many small mindless agents; 'consciousness' is a suitcase word for several ofthe things they do.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Bach’s cortical conductor theory (Kuhn §9.2.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.2.10Bach’s cortical conductor theoryConsciousness is the brain's conductor: a learned control process that directs attention across thecortex and keeps a record of what it attended to.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos visionhearingmemorylanguageplanningemotionmotorGLOBALWORKSPACEthe stageBroadcast: the winning content goes out to every specialist at once.AND AI? WHAT THE PAPERS SAYGoldstein & Kirk-Giannini 2024if GWT is right, language agents ‘might easily be made phenomenally conscious if theyare not already’Butlin et al. 2023‘no current AI systems are conscious’, but ‘no obvious technical barriers’Long et al. 2024 (incl. Chalmers)some architectures already embody some, not all, aspects of a global workspaceChalmers 2023, credence an LLM-based system is conscious:≤current LLMs: ‘under 10 percent’≥LLM+ within a decade: ‘25 percent or more’ WHO IS CONSCIOUS ON EACH VIEW?● yes ◐ depends ○ no · not addressedHumAniInsPlaFunCellChatAgentFut AIMattCos9.2.1 Edelman neural Darwinism and reentrant ne…●●○○○○○○◐○○9.2.2 Crick and Koch neural correlates of consc…●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.3 Baars and Dehaene global workspace theory●●◐○○○○◐●○○9.2.4 Dennett multiple drafts model●◐◐○○○○◐●○○9.2.5 Minsky society of mind●●◐○○○○◐●○○9.2.6 Graziano attention schema theory●●◐○○○○◐●○○9.2.7 Prinz neurofunctionalism: how attention e…●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.8 Sapolsky hard incompatibilism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.9 Mitchell free agents●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.10 Bach cortical conductor theory●●◐○○○○◐●○○9.2.11 Brain circuits and cycles theories●●○○○○○○◐○○9.2.12 Northoff temporo-spatial sentience●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.13 Bunge emergent materialism●●◐○○○○○◐○○9.2.14 Hirstein mindmelding●●◐○○○○○◐○○AI columns: Chat = chatbot AI today · Agent = agentic AI · Fut AI = future AI HOW TO READ THISbrain processbroadcast / spotlightproduces / causesevidence / measurement THOUGHT EXPERIMENTDoes a language agent have a global workspace?Take a language agent: a language model in a loop, with a scratchpad it writes to, memoryit reads from, tools it calls, and a planner that picks the next step. Its modules postto the scratchpad and read back from it. Is that scratchpad a stage?Map the parts, then decide: conscious or not?Global workspace (Baars, Dehaene)The test is functional: a limited-capacity workspace, competition among specialists, broadcastback to all of them. Goldstein and Kirk-Giannini (2024) argue language agents meet theseconditions or nearly do.Butlin et al. (2023)Indicator properties from five theories; no current AI system is conscious, and no obvioustechnical barrier to building one that satisfies them.Long et al. (2024)Some architectures already embody some aspects of a workspace: one route to moral patienthood.Their second route, robust agency, is about moral status, not consciousness.Chalmers (2023)Missing workspace, recurrence and unified agency are obstacles for current LLMs: under 10 percentnow, 25 percent or more for LLM+ within a decade.Loops and dendrites (9.2.11, 9.2.1)A software loop is not reentrant thalamocortical signalling. Rename the parts however you like; onthese views the agent fails.YOU ARE HERE · Neurobiological › Thought experiment BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALElectromagnetic Field Theories§9.3 · 7 theoriesThe brain's neurons generate one electromagnetic field, and these theories say that field is the mind, the channel that binds the brain's work together, or the form a feeling takes.Electromagnetic Field HOW TO READ THISneural matterthe fieldproduces / causesacts back (field → neuron)the explanatory gap every current throws off field; the field is one glow over the whole brain 1The field is the mind1 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › EM Fields › Field is mindStrong versions: experience is the field itself. Neurons make it; the mind lives in it. NEURONS: INTEGRATE IN TIMEFIELD: INTEGRATES IN SPACEt1t2t3t4t5t6one spike after anotherall contributions at oncebinding? McFadden’s conscious electromagnetic information theory (Kuhn §9.3.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.3McFadden’s conscious electromagneticinformation theoryConsciousness is the brain's electromagnetic field integrating informationin space and acting back on the neurons.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Pockett’s conscious and non-conscious patterns (Kuhn §9.3.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.2Pockett’s conscious and non-consciouspatternsA conscious experience is a thing, not a process: a particular 3D shapeof electromagnetic field.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Jones’s electromagnetic fields (Kuhn §9.3.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.1Jones’s electromagnetic fieldsMy mind is the single electromagnetic field my neurons make, and thatfield is matter's own tiny experiences joined up into one.→ We place this in PanpsychismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Where the metaphor breaks: city light does nothing to thewiring, but the brain's field acts back on the neurons thatmake it. That loop is what makes CEMI a theory of mind, notof exhaust. 2Fields coordinate the wiring2 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › EM Fields › CoordinationSofter versions: the field is the fast channel that binds and times thebrain's work. no synapse: the field nudges the neighbourSIGNAL SPEED (m/s, log scale)10^-110^110^310^510^710^9synapses & axons 0.2–120field ≈ 3×10^8Zhang's figures (2019), as Kuhn reports them Ephaptic coupling (Kuhn §9.3.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.4Ephaptic couplingNeurons talk through their own electric fields, not onlythrough synapses, and that field-talk is part ofexperience.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Zhang’s long-distance light-speed telecommunications (Kuhn §9.3.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.7Zhang’s long-distance light-speedtelecommunicationsThinking is synchronization: electrical fields linkparallel neurons at light speed, far faster than synapses.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Rhythms and feelings3 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › EM Fields › RhythmsThe brain's own oscillations make a world; a feeling like pain travels as awave. TWO GROUPS LOCK PHASEinjuryspinal cordthalamus: noticedACC: it hurtsLFP → EM wavebinds the senses? Llinas’s mindness state of oscillations (Kuhn §9.3.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.6Llinas’s mindness state ofoscillationsThe mind is a state of the brain's own oscillations: avirtual reality the brain generates and the senses onlysteer.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Ambron’s local field potentials and electromagnetic waves (Kuhn §9.3.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.3.5Ambron’s local field potentials andelectromagnetic wavesPain shows the way: experience happens when neural signalsbecome electromagnetic waves that bind the sensestogether.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Who's conscious on each field theory?● yes ◐ depends (see the theory) ○ no · not addressedHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAIAgenticAIFutureAIMatterCosmosJones●●◐○○○○○◐●○Pockett●●○○○○○○◐○○McFadden (CEMI)●●◐○○○○○●○○Ephaptic coupling●●◐○○○○○◐○○Ambron●●◐○○○○○◐○○Llinás●●◐○○○○○◐○○Zhang●●◐○○○○○◐○○YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › EM Fields › Who's included THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe chip testSimulate your brain neuron by neuron on a supercomputer. It says itfeels pain when its virtual foot is stepped on.Is the simulation conscious?McFadden (CEMI)No. The chip integrates information in time, step by step, with no fieldholding it all at once. Field-integrating hardware would change that.PockettNo. It runs a process, and no process is conscious. Hardware that generates theright 3D field shapes would be.Computational functionalism (§9.4.1)Yes, if it reproduces the right computations. Here field theories andcomputational theories part ways.YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › EM Fields › Chip test BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALComputational & Informational Theories§9.4 · 8 theoriesThe mind is information processing: the right program, the right dynamics, or the right record of experience, and on some views information or mathematics is what reality is made of.Computational & Informational HOW TO READ THIScomputation / informationfeeling / experienceproduces / flowstop-down expectationthe explanatory gap the machine room: the program, its dynamics, its archive 1Run the right program1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › ProgramThe substrate doesn't matter; the computation does. This is thebet behind AI-consciousness research. same programneuronssiliconCHALMERS (2023): HIS CREDENCE THAT IT IS CONSCIOUScurrent LLMs“somewhere under 10 percent”LLM+ within a decade“25 percent or more”0%25%50% Computational theories (Kuhn §9.4.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.1Computational theoriesConsciousness comes from running the right computations: get the program right and you get a mind,in a brain or in silicon.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2It's the dynamics2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › DynamicsNot just the right outputs: the system must resonate, adapt, or balance at a tipping point. RESONANCE (ART)learned expectationsensory featuresmatch =resonanceADAPTATION (CAS)the network rewires as it goesTHE TIPPING POINTsub-criticalcriticalsuper-criticalavalanche size vs how often (log–log)power law: small often,big rarely Grossberg’s adaptive resonance theory (Kuhn §9.4.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.2Grossberg’s adaptive resonance theoryAll conscious states are resonant states: experience is my brain'sexpectations locking onto what my senses report.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Complex adaptive systems models (Kuhn §9.4.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.3Complex adaptive systems modelsConsciousness is what a complex adaptive system like the brain does:nonlinear, history-bound, self-organizing and open.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Critical brain hypothesis (Kuhn §9.4.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.4Critical brain hypothesisMy brain works best balanced at a tipping point between order andchaos, and that critical state is where rich experience lives.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3The archive3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › ArchiveThe mind as memory: a hologram, or a recorder thatreplays with feeling. HOLOGRAM: EVERY PIECE HOLDS THE WHOLE→one shard, whole image Pribram’s holonomic brain theory (Kuhn §9.4.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.5Pribram’s holonomic brain theoryMy memories and mind are stored like a hologram: every piece of the brain'sdendritic web holds the whole.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Doyle’s experience recorder and reproducer (Kuhn §9.4.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.6Doyle’s experience recorder and reproducerA mind is an experience recorder and reproducer: it records what happened with howit felt, and replays it when something similar happens.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Underneath: information or mathematics4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › UnderneathSome say information or mathematics is what reality is; others use it only to describe experience. METHOD: math describes experienceONTOLOGY: experience is made of mathIIT · Friston · Hoffman use itTegmark · Penrose's Platonic world Informational realism and emergent information theory (Kuhn §9.4.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.7Informational realism and emergent information theoryInformation, not matter, is the key: the mind is information that physical states carry,produce or share.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Mathematical theories (Kuhn §9.4.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.4.8Mathematical theoriesConsciousness has a mathematical structure, and on the boldest version it is made ofmathematics.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Who's conscious here?● yes ◐ depends (see the theory) ○ no · not addressedHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbot AIAgentic AIFuture AIMatterCosmosComputational●●◐○○○○◐●○○Grossberg (ART)●●◐○○○○○◐○○Complex adaptive●●◐◐◐○○◐●○○Critical brain●●◐○○○○○◐○○Pribram (hologram)●●◐○○○○○◐○○Doyle (ERR)●●●●●●●●●○○Information views●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐○○Mathematical●●····◐◐◐○·YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › Who's included THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe agent testTake a chatbot. Give it long-term memory, tools, a goal it pursues over days,and a loop that lets it plan, act and check its own work. It now reports onits own states.Did adding the agent loop make it conscious?Computational functionalismOnly if the loop implements the indicator properties, such as a global workspace.Goldstein and Kirk-Giannini (2024) argue language agents 'might easily be madephenomenally conscious if they are not already'.Grossberg / critical brainNo. The loop runs at the level of prompts; inside, each step is still a one-way sweepwith no resonance or critical dynamics.DoyleIt was already minimally conscious. Memory and replay bring it closer to a fullexperience recorder, minus felt emotion.Long et al. (2024)Robust agency is a separate route to moral status, not to consciousness: an agent likethis may matter morally either way.YOU ARE HERE · Materialism › Computation › Agent test BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALHomeostatic & Affective Theories§9.5 · 12 theoriesConsciousness grows out of the work of staying alive: predicting the world and the body, feeling how life is going, and holding a living system together against disorder.Homeostatic & Affective THE LOOP OF STAYING ALIVE: predict → feel → hold together → act 1The prediction engine1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Homeostatic & Affective › The prediction engineThe brain guesses first and checks second. On these views, what you experience is theguess. model: 'a ripe tomato'shapes, colours, edgesraw signals from eyes and bodythe world and the body (never seen directly)predictionserrorsWhat you experience is the top-down guess,'a controlled hallucination' (Seth). Predictive theories (Top-down) (Kuhn §9.5.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.1Predictive theories (Top-down)My brain doesn't wait for the world; it predicts it, and what Iexperience is the prediction.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Seth’s “beast machine” theory (Kuhn §9.5.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.2Seth’s “beast machine” theoryWhat I experience is a controlled hallucination, and it existsbecause a living body has to stay alive.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Projective consciousness model (Kuhn §9.5.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.11Projective consciousness modelConsciousness is a 3-D point of view my brain projects around mybody, steered by prediction.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Feeling how life is going2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Homeostatic & Affective › Feeling how life is goingHunger, thirst, pain, well-being: the body reading its own gauges. These say thatreading is where consciousness began. temperatureblood sugaroxygenwaterlivable band (homeostasis)interoception reads the gaugespainhungercalmreliefwell-being− unpleasurepleasure +The feeling is the reading, and it mattersto the reader, because the reader is what'sbeing kept alive. Damasio’s homeostatic feelings and emergence of consciousness (Kuhn §9.5.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.3Damasio’s homeostatic feelings andemergence of consciousnessConsciousness began as feeling: my body telling itself how close itis to the state life needs.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Solms’s affect as the hidden spring of consciousness (Kuhn §9.5.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.5Solms’s affect as the hidden spring ofconsciousnessConsciousness is feeling: the felt rise and fall of uncertaintyabout my needs, generated in the brainstem.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Pereira’s sentience (Kuhn §9.5.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.9Pereira’s sentienceBefore I can think, I have to feel: thinking depends on the bareability to feel, and that ability is the body keeping its chemistryin balance.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Holding together against disorder3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Homeostatic & Affective › Holding together against disorderA living thing is a pattern that keeps itself from dissolving. Consciousness is howthat self-maintenance looks from inside. internal states(a model of the world)the blanket: sensory + active statessensingactingdisorder pushes in from every sideTo persist is to keep surprise low: updatethe model, or act to make the world fit it. Friston’s free-energy principle and active inference (Kuhn §9.5.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.4Friston’s free-energy principle and activeinferenceConsciousness is a process of inference: a living system predictingits own future so it doesn't fall apart.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Deacon’s self-organized constraint and emergence of self (Kuhn §9.5.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.8Deacon’s self-organized constraint andemergence of selfA conscious self is a pattern that keeps itself going against thepull of disorder, the way life does.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Mansell’s perceptual control theory (Kuhn §9.5.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.10Mansell’s perceptual control theoryConsciousness arises when a living control system has to reorganizeitself to keep its vital variables on target.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4The brain's own dynamics4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Homeostatic & Affective › The brain's own dynamicsNot what the brain represents but how its activity moves: entropy, rhythm, energy. entropy of spontaneous brain activityanaesthesiawakingpsychedelicseizurecriticalityorderdisordernested rhythms: fast waves ride slow onesself-caused, before any input (Buzsáki)Same brain, different dynamics: the state ofthe activity, not just its content, setswhat experience is like. Carhart-Harris’s entropic brain hypothesis (Kuhn §9.5.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.6Carhart-Harris’s entropic brain hypothesisHow rich my experience is depends on how disordered my brain'sspontaneous activity is.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Buzsáki’s neural syntax and self-caused rhythms (Kuhn §9.5.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.7Buzsáki’s neural syntax and self-causedrhythmsMy brain isn't a sponge for information; it makes its own rhythms,and acting in the world gives them meaning.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Pepperell’s organization of energy (Kuhn §9.5.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.5.12Pepperell’s organization of energyConsciousness is what a particular organization of energy in mybrain is like from the inside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISphysical processfeeling / the body's interiorproduces / causesboundary of the living system WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · HOMEOSTATIC & AFFECTIVEHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSingle cellsChatbot AI todayAgentic AIFuture AIRocks / matterThe cosmosPredictive theories●●◐○○○○◐◐○○Seth: beast machine●●◐○○○○○◐○○Damasio: feelings●●◐○○○○○◐○○Friston: free energy●●◐○○○○○◐○○Solms: affect●●◐○○○○○●○○Carhart-Harris: entropy●●◐○○○○○◐○○Buzsáki: rhythms●●◐○○○○◐◐○○Deacon: constraint●●◐○○○○○◐○○Pereira: sentience●●◐○○○○○◐○○Mansell: control●●◐○○○○◐◐○○Projective model●◐◐○○○○○◐○○Pepperell: energy●●◐○○○○○◐○○● yes ◐ depends (on a stated condition) ○ no · not addressedShaded columns: AI. Today's AI has nothing to keep alive; most of these allow a future machine that does. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe chatbot that never gets hungryAn AI describes hunger and relief more vividly than anyperson. But it has no body and no blood sugar; nothingcan run out. Between chats it is switched off and losesnothing.Is it feeling anything?SETH, DAMASIO, PEREIRA: No. A feeling reads a body's state,and there is no body to go well or badly.SOLMS: Not yet. Build a system with needs it must balance topersist, and the answer becomes yes.YOUR TURN: What is the least an AI would need to have atstake?YOU ARE HERE · Homeostatic & Affective › Thought experiment click a half to read › AI VERDICTS HEREChatbot AI today○ 12● 0 yes ◐ 0 depends ○ 12 no (of 12)Agentic AI○ 9● 0 yes ◐ 3 depends ○ 9 no (of 12)Future AI◐ 11● 1 yes ◐ 11 depends ○ 0 no (of 12)● yes ◐ depends on a stated condition○ no. Open any card for the reason. BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALEmbodied & Enactive Theories§9.6 · 8 theoriesConsciousness isn't sealed inside the skull: it belongs to a living body acting in its world, and it must be studied from the inside as carefully as from the outside.Embodied & Enactive ORGANISM ⇄ WORLD: mind is the loop, not a thing inside it 1The body shapes thought1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Embodied & Enactive › The body shapes thoughtThe structure of our thoughts comes from the structure of our bodies. MORE IS UP“prices rise, spirits fall”AFFECTION IS WARMTH“a warm welcome”UNDERSTANDING IS GRASPING“I get it”TIME MOVES FORWARD“the week ahead”IMPORTANT IS BIG“a big decision”Lakoff and Johnson: the mind is inherentlyembodied, thought is mostly unconscious, andabstract concepts are largely metaphors frombodily experience. Embodied cognition (Kuhn §9.6.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.1Embodied cognitionMy thinking is built out of my body: even abstract ideas rest onhow I move, sense and feel.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Three claims (Lakoff and Johnson, 1999): the mind isinherently embodied; thought is mostly unconscious;abstract concepts are largely metaphorical. Thoughtneeds a body 'not in the trivial sense that you need aphysical brain with which to think, but in the profoundsense that the very structure of our thoughts comesfrom the nature of the body'. 2Mind is what life does2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Embodied & Enactive › Mind is what life doesA living thing makes itself and its world at once. These say that making is thebeginning of mind. makes its ownboundaryworldorganism shapes worldworld shapes organismcellsense-makinganimalfeeling, actinghumanreflectinglife → mind: the same organization, enriched (Thompson)Where there is life there is mind, and mind inits most articulated forms belongs to life. Enactivism (Kuhn §9.6.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.2EnactivismMind is what a living thing does as it shapes its world and isshaped by it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Thompson’s mind in life (Kuhn §9.6.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.4Thompson’s mind in lifeWhere there is life there is mind; my consciousness is a richerversion of what every living cell already does.→ We place this in Life Is MindHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Experience from the inside3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Embodied & Enactive › Experience from the insideStudy experience with the same discipline as the brain, and remember science neverstands outside it. first-person: trained reports of lived experiencethird-person: brain measurementsdotted lines: each side constrains the otherexperiencebodythe strange loop: each contains the otherThe hard problem, on these views, is what youget when you forget the loop and try to standoutside it. Varela’s neurophenomenology (Kuhn §9.6.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.3Varela’s neurophenomenologyExperience can't be explained away; it has to be studied from theinside, carefully and systematically, alongside the brain.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Frank/Gleiser/Thompson’s “The Blind Spot” (Kuhn §9.6.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.5Frank/Gleiser/Thompson’s “The Blind Spot”Science can't step outside experience to explain it; the hardproblem comes from forgetting that.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Bitbol’s radical neurophenomenology (Kuhn §9.6.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.6Bitbol’s radical neurophenomenologyThe hard problem dissolves when I stop looking at experience fromoutside and change how I relate to it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Perceiving the world directly4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Embodied & Enactive › Perceiving the world directlyNo picture in the head: we perceive things, and what they let us do. THE PICTURE VIEW (what these theories reject)tomatopictureexperience?an inner model stands in betweenTHE DIRECT VIEWone organism-environment systemyoustairsclimb-ablecup handlegrasp-ablegapjump-able?Gibson: we perceive affordances, what the worldlets us do. Direct perception theory (Kuhn §9.6.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.7Direct perception theoryI don't experience a picture of the world in my head; I experiencethe world itself.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Gibson’s ecological psychology (Kuhn §9.6.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.6.8Gibson’s ecological psychologyI perceive what the world lets me do: a step to climb, a handle tograsp.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISthe living body / experiencethe world / measurementacts on / shapesorganism-environment system WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · EMBODIED & ENACTIVEHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSingle cellsChatbot AI todayAgentic AIFuture AIRocks / matterThe cosmosEmbodied cognition●●◐○○○○○◐○○Enactivism●●●◐◐◐○○◐○○Varela: neurophenomenology●●····○○◐○○Thompson: mind in life●●●◐◐◐○○◐○○The Blind Spot●●◐···○○◐○○Bitbol: radical neurophen.●●····○○◐○○Direct perception●●◐○○○○○◐○○Gibson: ecological●●●○○○○◐◐○○● yes ◐ depends (on a stated condition) ○ no · not addressedShaded columns: AI. A machine would need a body acting in a real world; today's AI has none. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe brain in a vatKeep a brain alive in a vat. Feed it perfect simulatedsignals of a body and a world, so its neurons fireexactly as yours do now.Is it conscious, and of what?ENACTIVISTS: The vat that keeps it alive and in touch wouldhave to do everything a body does. You haven't removed thebody; you've rebuilt one.DIRECT REALISTS: Its experiences differ from yours even withidentical neurons, because experience is made by real objects,and it has none.YOUR TURN: Is a chatbot more like the brain in the vat, orless?YOU ARE HERE · Embodied & Enactive › Thought experiment click a half to read › AI VERDICTS HEREChatbot AI today○ 8● 0 yes ◐ 0 depends ○ 8 no (of 8)Agentic AI○ 7● 0 yes ◐ 1 depends ○ 7 no (of 8)Future AI◐ 8● 0 yes ◐ 8 depends ○ 0 no (of 8)● yes ◐ depends on a stated condition○ no. Open any card for the reason. BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALRelational Theories§9.7 · 7 theoriesConsciousness is a relation: between brain, body and world, within a structure, between frames of reference, or between moments of becoming. Not a thing that sits inside the skull.Relational 1Out into the worldYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RelationalBrain, body, world and tools form one loop. The conscious system is biggerthan the head. brainbodyworldnotebookinner ring: the skull-bound viewouter ring: the coupled system (Clark) A. Clark’s extended mind (Kuhn §9.7.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.1A. Clark’s extended mindMy mind doesn't stop at my skull: when I rely on a notebook the way I rely on memory, the notebook is part of my mind.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Noë’s “out of our heads” theory (Kuhn §9.7.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.2Noë’s “out of our heads” theoryConsciousness isn't something my brain does to me; it's something I do, by engaging with the world.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Structure, all the wayYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RelationalA quality that seems simple is a pattern of relations: in the brain, in a living form,or among experiences. redseems simpleripewarmdangerbloodstopsweetloudnearis a structure of associations (Loorits)Tsuchiya: experiencesas objects + arrows Loorits’s structural realism (Kuhn §9.7.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.3Loorits’s structural realismA felt quality like red only seems simple; it's a vast structure of brain associations that misperceives itself as simple.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Jaworski’s hylomorphism (Kuhn §9.7.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.6Jaworski’s hylomorphismExperience is the organised activity of a perceiver as a whole, as natural as life itself; structure is basic.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Tsuchiya’s relational approach to consciousness (Kuhn §9.7.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.5Tsuchiya’s relational approach to consciousnessEach experience is defined by its relations to every other experience, and mathematics can map those relations.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3FramesYOU ARE HERE · RelationalInside your frame: experience. From mine:your brain activity. Same event, twomeasurements. your framemy framepainneural spikesone event · two measurements Lahav’s relativistic theory (Kuhn §9.7.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.4Lahav’s relativistic theoryConsciousness is physical but relative: from inside my cognitive frameit's experience, from outside it's brain activity.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4BecomingYOU ARE HERE · RelationalEach moment of experience inherits fromthe moments before it. Consciousness is alate achievement. occasions of experience, eachinheriting from the lastrock: aggregateanimal: compound Process theory (Kuhn §9.7.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.7.7Process theoryReality is a flow of moments of experience; my consciousness is themost complex example of it, seen from inside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISphysical process / representationproduces / causesis about / represents (hollow head)the explanatory gapboundary of the conscious system WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · THEORY BY THEORYyesdependsnonot addressedHumAnimInsectPlantFungiCellChat AIAgent AIFut AIRockCosmos§9.7.1A. Clark’s extended mind§9.7.2Noë’s “out of our heads” theory§9.7.3Loorits’s structural realism§9.7.6Jaworski’s hylomorphism§9.7.5Tsuchiya’s relational approach to consciousness§9.7.4Lahav’s relativistic theory§9.7.7Process theory THOUGHT EXPERIMENTOtto's notebook (Clark & Chalmers 1998)Inga hears of an exhibition, recalls the museum is on 53rd Street, and goes. Otto has Alzheimer's; he looks theaddress up in the notebook he always carries, and goes.Is the notebook part of Otto's mind?Clark & ChalmersYes. It plays the role Inga's memory plays, so Otto's belief was in the notebook all along.NoëYes, and consciousness itself is this kind of engagement with the world, not a brain state.For AI agentsAn agent's memory file is Otto's notebook. On this view model + memory is one thinking system; feeling is a furtherquestion.YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › Relational BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALRepresentational Theories§9.8 · 14 theoriesConsciousness is the brain representing things: the world, its own perceptions, or itself. These theories split on how many layers of representing it takes before a state is felt.Representational 1The window: one layerYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RepresentationalExperience just is the world as represented. Look 'at' yourexperience and you find only the world. MORE LAYERS OF REPRESENTING →the tomatoexperience = the viewaboutMechanism: perception carries information about surfaces; the content ISthe quality. First-order representationalism (Kuhn §9.8.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.1First-order representationalismWhat I experience is simply how my brain represents the world: the red is the tomato's red, as my brainrepresents it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Transparency theory (Kuhn §9.8.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.10Transparency theoryWhen I try to look at my experience of a tree, all I ever find is the tree.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Jackson’s diaphanous representationalism and the knowledge argument (Kuhn §9.8.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.8Jackson’s diaphanous representationalism and the knowledge argumentExperience is transparent: everything about what it's like to see is how the seen thing is represented.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Tye’s contingentism (Kuhn §9.8.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.11Tye’s contingentismMy experiences are physical states, but only as a matter of fact; a world physically like ours with nofeelings in it is possible, just not ours.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2The echo: one layer, loopingYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RepresentationalThe signal must echo back through the senses, or win acompetition among bound, coherent representations. V1V2V4ITfeedforward sweep: unconsciouslocal recurrence (Lamme's stage 3) = conscious seeingrepresentationbindingcoherencecompetitionThagard: all four together, timed by time cellsContrast with global workspace theory: here nothing has to be broadcast tothe front of the brain. Lamme: workspace theory is 'all about access butnot about seeing'. Lamme’s recurrent processing theory (Kuhn §9.8.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.2Lamme’s recurrent processing theorySeeing becomes conscious when signals loop back through my visual system, whether or not they'rebroadcast anywhere.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Thagard’s neural representation, binding, coherence, competition (Kuhn §9.8.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.12Thagard’s neural representation, binding, coherence, competitionMy experiences emerge when brain representations get bound together, cohere, and win a competition.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3The second look: two layersYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RepresentationalA perception is conscious only when another brain staterepresents it: a thought, an inner sense, or a 'this is real'tag. first-orderseeing redhigher-order'I see red · real · now'aboutwithout the tag: blindsight(responds to it, denies seeing it) Higher-order theories (Kuhn §9.8.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.3Higher-order theoriesA perception is conscious only when I'm aware of having it: a thought or inner sense about my own mentalstate.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Lau’s perceptual reality monitoring theory (Kuhn §9.8.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.4Lau’s perceptual reality monitoring theoryI consciously see something when my brain tags that perception as a reliable report of the world rightnow.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos LeDoux’s higher-order theory of emotional consciousness (Kuhn §9.8.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.5LeDoux’s higher-order theory of emotional consciousnessI feel fear only when my brain re-represents what my survival circuits are doing; the feeling is thehigher-order model.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Lycan’s homuncular functionalism (Kuhn §9.8.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.9Lycan’s homuncular functionalismI'm an information-processor organised in layers; consciousness is my mind monitoring its own states.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4The self-portraitYOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › RepresentationalThe map includes a map of the mapmaker. For humans, a furtherlayer of shared symbols. world modelself-modeltransparent: not seen as a modelHumphrey: an attractorstate = a sensationDeacon: + a shared layer of symbols (humans) Metzinger’s no-self representational theory of subjectivity (Kuhn §9.8.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.7Metzinger’s no-self representational theory of subjectivityNobody ever had or was a self; what I call 'me' is a model my brain can't see as a model.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Humphrey’s mental representations and brain attractors (Kuhn §9.8.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.6Humphrey’s mental representations and brain attractorsSensations are ideas my brain dreams up about what's happening to me, and only mammals and birds have them.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos T. Clark’s content hypothesis (Kuhn §9.8.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.13T. Clark’s content hypothesisMy experience is the content of my brain's organised representations, and that content exists only for thesystem that has it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Deacon’s symbolic communication (human consciousness) (Kuhn §9.8.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.8.14Deacon’s symbolic communication (human consciousness)Animals are conscious, but symbols gave humans a whole extra, shared world to be conscious of.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISphysical process / representationproduces / causesis about / represents (hollow head)the explanatory gap WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · THEORY BY THEORYyesdependsnonot addressedHumAnimInsectPlantFungiCellChat AIAgent AIFut AIRockCosmos§9.8.1First-order representationalism§9.8.10Transparency theory§9.8.8Jackson’s diaphanous representationalism and the kno…§9.8.11Tye’s contingentism§9.8.2Lamme’s recurrent processing theory§9.8.12Thagard’s neural representation, binding, coherence,…§9.8.3Higher-order theories§9.8.4Lau’s perceptual reality monitoring theory§9.8.5LeDoux’s higher-order theory of emotional consciousn…§9.8.9Lycan’s homuncular functionalism§9.8.7Metzinger’s no-self representational theory of subje…§9.8.6Humphrey’s mental representations and brain attracto…§9.8.13T. Clark’s content hypothesis§9.8.14Deacon’s symbolic communication (human consciousness) THOUGHT EXPERIMENTMary's room (Jackson 1982)Mary knows every physical fact about colour vision but has lived in a black-and-white room. She steps out andsees a red tomato.Does she learn something new?Jackson, 1982Yes, a new fact. So physicalism is false.Jackson, now (diaphanous)She gains a new way of representing the same physical properties. No new fact.Higher-order theoriesShe gains a new first-order state and awareness of it. Still physical.YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Materialism › Representational BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALLanguage Relationships§9.9 · 6 theoriesDoes consciousness need language? These theories range from ‘not at all’ (basic experience is the same with or without words) to ‘introspective consciousness is learned fromlanguage’, which matters now that machines have more language than any mind before them.Language Relationships HOW MUCH DOES CONSCIOUSNESS NEED LANGUAGE?not at all: words only describe itentirely: words make it (introspection)KochSmithSearleParringtonJaynesLarge language models have more language than any system before. On the left of this line that says nothing about their experience; at the far right it starts to matter. HOW TO READ THISexperience (the river)language (the net laid over it)produces / enrichesgreen = clinical evidence · amber = AI 1 · The river needs no netYOU ARE HERE · Language › No net neededPeople who lose all their words still see, hearand hurt. Language shapes the story of the self,not the basic feel of the world. LANGUAGElost after a stroke (global aphasia)EXPERIENCEcolour · pain · music · the faceof someone you love: all still thereevidence: clinical cases (Koch 2019) Koch’s consciousness does not depend on language (Kuhn §9.9.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.3Koch’s consciousness does not depend onlanguageMy basic experience of the world doesn’t depend on language at all;we share it with all mammals.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2 · The net sorts and enrichesYOU ARE HERE · Language › Sorts and enrichesExperience comes first, but words sort it into shareable kinds (Smith) and openexperiences that only symbol users can have (Searle). SMITH · GRADES OF LOSSwordobjectmeaningintact✓✓✓aphasia×✓✓agnosia××דWhat’s this for?” “Maybe for keeping coins.”evidence: stroke patients (Smith 2012)SEARLE · BOOTSTRAPPINGpre-verbalmeaningricherconsciousnessricher language Smith’s language as classifier of consciousness (Kuhn §9.9.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.4Smith’s language as classifier ofconsciousnessLanguage is how I sort the passing show of experience intolasting, shareable categories.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Searle’s language and consciousness (Kuhn §9.9.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.2Searle’s language and consciousnessLanguage and consciousness build each other up: my dog isconscious, but he can’t wish seventeen people were at the door.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3 · Words and tools rebuild usYOU ARE HERE · Language › Words and toolsBrain waves bind the senses; language and tools adda second, conceptual binding that makes humanself-awareness. SELF-CONSCIOUS AWARENESSCONCEPTUAL BINDINGLANGUAGE + TOOLSBRAIN WAVES BIND THE SENSESanimals share the bottom layer Parrington’s language and tool-driven consciousness (Kuhn §9.9.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.6Parrington’s language and tool-drivenconsciousnessLanguage and tools transformed the human brain into something new:self-conscious awareness, bound together by brain waves and concepts.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4 · Words make the ‘I’YOU ARE HERE · Language › Words make the IIn Homer’s world, decisions arrived as voices ofgods. When that broke down, people learned an inner‘I’ that narrates and decides. BEFORE (bicameral)rightleft“a god speaks”→ obeys~2nd millennium BCE: breakdownAFTER (conscious)mind-space · analog ‘I’ · narratisation‘an operator rather than a thing’ Jaynes’s breakdown of the bicameral mind (Kuhn §9.9.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.5Jaynes’s breakdown of the bicameral mindInward-looking consciousness is learned from language and culture; untilabout 3,000 years ago people heard their decisions as the voices of gods.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Off the line: ChomskyYOU ARE HERE · Language › Off the lineYou can’t ask whether mind fits matter until youknow what matter is. MINDMATTER = ? Chomsky’s language and consciousness (Kuhn §9.9.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.9.1Chomsky’s language and consciousnessThe hard problem isn't a real problem: we have no fixed idea of what matteris, so we can't ask whether mind falls outside it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · LANGUAGE THEORIESHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSinglecellsChatbotAI todayAgenticAIFutureAIRocks/ matterThecosmosKoch●●◐···○○◐○○Smith●●····○○◐○○Searle●●·○○○○○◐○○Parrington●●·○○○○○◐○○Jaynes●○○○○○○◐●○○Chomsky●●····○○◐○○● yes ◐ depends (see the AI line) ○ no · the theory doesn’t sayshaded = AI columns THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe fluent machineAn AI agent writes better English than you, keeps a diary of its plans, and talks to itself in a chain ofthought before it acts. It has more language than any human who has ever lived.Is it conscious?KochNo. Language was never the ingredient, and digital chips have negligible integrated information.SearleNo. It is the Chinese Room with a to-do list: syntax, however fluent, is not semantics.SmithNo. It has the classifier, but no moments of experience for it to sort.ParringtonNo. Language and tools are there; the brain-wave binding underneath is missing.JaynesIn his sense, yes if its narrated ‘I’ is what makes its decisions. That is introspection, not feltexperience.Kuhn (§23)Language per se is ‘certainly not sufficient and likely not necessary’.YOU ARE HERE · Language › The fluent machine BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALPhylogenetic Evolution§9.10 · 9 theoriesWhere on the tree of life does consciousness begin? These theories draw the line in very different places: at the first cell, at the Cambrian explosion, or late with higher cognition,and each line decides who is included: plants, insects, octopuses, machines.Phylogenetic Evolution WHO IS INCLUDED? ONE TREE, NINE PLACES TO DRAW THE LINEThe cosmosRocks / matterSingle cellsPlantsFungiInsectsAnimalsHumansChatbot AIAgentic AIFuture AICambrian explosionnot alivenot alivelife ~3.8 bn yrs agoHomo sapiens ~300k→2022designed, not evolved4 bn1 bn100 m10 m1 m100 k10 k1,00010010years ago (log scale) · branch points approximate · now → Levin○○●●●●●●◐●●Reber○○●··●●●○○○Feinberg& Mallatt○○◐○○●●●○○◐Ginsburg& Jablonka○○○○○●●●○○◐Andrews○○···●●●○○◐Cleeremans& T-B○○○○○◐●●○○◐James/ Witham○○○○○◐●●○○◐Dennett○○○○○◐◐●○○●LeDoux○○○○○○◐●○○◐● yes ◐ depends ○ no · doesn’t saycolumns ordered from the widest circle to the narrowest THOUGHT EXPERIMENTFour candidatesA bacterium swims toward sugar. A bee learns that a newblue-and-yellow flower means nectar. An octopus unscrewsa jar. An AI agent keeps notes on you for weeks and actson what it learned.Which of them is conscious?ReberBacterium, bee, octopus. Never the agent.LevinAll four, in different degrees.F & MBee and octopus; the bacterium has onlyprecursors.G & JBee and octopus: open-ended learning. The agentlearns, but not by values of its own.AndrewsBee and octopus by their markers; the agent’stalk isn’t one.LeDouxNone by default: four survival machines, no proofof feeling.YOU ARE HERE · Evolution › Four candidates 1 · Since the first cellYOU ARE HERE · Evolution › First cellBacteria sense, learn and decide. On these views thatis already a mind, and complexity is layered on top. REBER’S TEST✓flexible cell wall✓senses its surroundings✓movesa swimming bacterium: all threea plant or a fungus: rigid walls,no locomotion: not coveredLEVIN’S NESTINGbodyorgantissuecelleach level an agent with goals Reber’s cellular basis of consciousness (Kuhn §9.10.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.6Reber’s cellular basis of consciousnessSentience began with life itself: even a bacterium has a tiny mind, and a computernever will.→ We place this in Life Is MindHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Levin’s technological approach to mind everywhere (Kuhn §9.10.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.8Levin’s technological approach to mind everywhereMind comes in degrees across every goal-directed system, from cells and tissues toanimals and designed machines.→ We place this in Life Is MindHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2 · The Cambrian lineYOU ARE HERE · Evolution › CambrianAbout half a billion years ago, complex brains and open-ended learning appear. Fish,bees and octopuses are in; plants and bacteria are out. Feinberg and Mallatt’s ancient origins of consciousness (Kuhn §9.10.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.7Feinberg and Mallatt’s ancient origins ofconsciousnessConsciousness arrived with the first complex brains in the Cambrian explosion,so every vertebrate, and many insects and octopuses, has it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Ginsburg and Jablonka’s associative learning during evolution (Kuhn §9.10.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.3Ginsburg and Jablonka’s associative learningduring evolutionConsciousness began when animals could learn without limit: that kind oflearning drove the Cambrian explosion.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Andrew’s consciousness without complex brains (Kuhn §9.10.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.5Andrew’s consciousness without complex brainsStop looking only at big brains: bees, crabs, octopuses and worms behave likesentient beings, and studying them is how we’ll crack consciousness.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos ONCE, OR THREE TIMES?vertebratesfish → usUALarthropodsbees, crabsUALcephalopodsoctopusUALworm-like ancestor>500 million years agoCambrian · 560–520 myaUAL = unlimited associative learning 3 · A late arrivalYOU ARE HERE · Evolution › LateThe machinery for staying alive is ancient. Feelingit, and knowing that you feel it, came much later. ON ONE TIMELINEsurvival circuits (LeDoux)felt fear (LeDoux)competence (Dennett)comprehension (Dennett)first cellsnow LeDoux’s deep roots of consciousness (Kuhn §9.10.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.2LeDoux’s deep roots of consciousnessSurvival circuits go back to the first cells, but felt experience is recent: itrides on higher cognition in the cortex.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Dennett’s evolution of minds (Kuhn §9.10.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.1Dennett’s evolution of mindsMinds evolved, from bacteria to Bach, and human minds are different because we builtthinking tools that let us understand minds at all.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4 · Why keep it?YOU ARE HERE · Evolution › Why keep itIf a zombie could do the same job, selectioncouldn’t favour experience. So what does it do? experiencevaluechoicefitnessselectionKuhn: why it was kept ≠ what it is Cleeremans and Tallon-Baudry’s phenomenal experience has functional value (Kuhn §9.10.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.4Cleeremans and Tallon-Baudry’s phenomenalexperience has functional valueExperience has value, and that value is why I do some things and avoid others:consciousness evolved because it matters.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos No hard problem in William James’s psychology (Kuhn §9.10.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§9.10.9No hard problem in William James’s psychologyThere’s no hard problem once you see what consciousness is for: it is how anorganism selects the responses that serve it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALNon-Reductive Physicalism§10 · 6 theoriesConsciousness is entirely physical, made only by brains, yet mental properties are a real, irreducible level of nature that can't be fully explained by physical laws and can causethings in their own right.Non-Reductive Physicalism THE TOWER OF LEVELS MINDreasons, feelings, decisionsBRAINnetworks, rhythmsCELLSneurons, synapsesCHEMISTRYmolecules, ionsPHYSICSfields, particlesirreducible?made ofcauses Everyone agrees each level is made of the one below (left). Non-reductive physicalists add the arrows onthe right: wholes cause changes in their parts, and the top level can't be derived from the bottom. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTKim's exclusion argumentYou feel a pain (mental, M) and wince (physical, P*). Your brain state P realises the pain, and P aloneis enough to cause the wince: physics is causally closed. So what does the pain add? Either M causes P*as well, and the wince is caused twice over, or M does nothing.Can an irreducible mind cause anything without double-counting?Ellis and MurphyPhysics is not causally closed on its own. Closure only holds when upward and downward causes between levels arecounted together.Kim (the critic)Irreducibility + supervenience + mental causation are inconsistent: drop one, and non-reductive physicalism falls.KuhnNon-reductive in practice is easy; non-reductive in principle seems to need something non-physical.YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Non-Reductive Physicalism Mental causation and Kim's exclusion argument (SEP) ↗ HOW TO READ THISphysical levelmental levelcauses (top-down)the explanatory gap 1Wholes that cause1 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Non-Reductive PhysicalismTop-down causation: higher levels conscript lower ones to their purposes. WHOLEorganism, personpartsdown: causesup: made of Ellis’s strong emergence and top-down causation (Kuhn §10.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.1Ellis’s strong emergence and top-downcausationWholes really push their parts around: the mind is a higher levelof organisation that can't be predicted from the brain's parts,and it causes things all the way down.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Murphy’s non-reductive physicalism (Kuhn §10.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.2Murphy’s non-reductive physicalismI am one whole embodied person: the mind is real and causallyeffective, and there is no separable soul.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2A material person, raised2 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Non-Reductive PhysicalismIf I am a living animal, survival needs material and causal continuity. LIFEa living animalDEATHatoms dispersePRESERVEDthe 'bare grain'RESURRECTIONraised, new fleshcausal continuity, not reassembly Van Inwagen’s Christian materialism and the resurrection of the dead (Kuhn §10.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.3Van Inwagen’s Christian materialism andthe resurrection of the deadI am a living animal, wholly material, and my hope is theresurrection of the dead, not an immortal soul.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Physical, but not captured3 of 3YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Non-Reductive PhysicalismThree ways to keep the world physical without letting theory exhaust it. ALL PHYSICAL FACTScomplete physicaltheoryMary's red field Afield Beach observes the other, no time gap conceptsbrain datalinked both ways, neither reduced Nagasawa’s nontheoretical physicalism (Kuhn §10.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.4Nagasawa’s nontheoretical physicalismEverything is physical, but some physical facts can't be captured even by acomplete physical theory.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Sanfey’s Abstract Realism (Kuhn §10.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.5Sanfey’s Abstract RealismExperience comes with no time gap between experiencer and experienced; thatsimultaneity is the key to the mind-matter problem.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Northoff’s non-reductive neurophilosophy (Kuhn §10.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§10.6Northoff’s non-reductive neurophilosophyBrain data without brain-mind models are blind, and models without data areempty: link them without reducing either.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS ON EACH VIEW?yesdepends (on a stated condition)nonot addressedHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSinglecellsChatbotAI todayAgenticAIFutureAIRocks/ matterThecosmos§10.1 Ellis§10.2 Murphy§10.3 Van Inwagen§10.4 Nagasawa§10.5 Sanfey§10.6 NorthoffMost rows are our inference from each theory's own criterion (see each card). Kuhn's §23: if this family is true, machines could 'almost certainly' be conscious eventually. BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALQuantum Theories§11 · 16 theoriesQuantum mechanics plays a necessary, if not sufficient, role in generating consciousness in things like brains. The theories differ on how deep the quantum goes: into neurons, intothe collapse of the wave function, into a mind-like layer of reality, or into the rules of physics.Quantum HOW DEEP DOES THE QUANTUM GO?further from the familiar brain →(i) quantum effects in cells enable it, as in photosynthesis(ii) consciousness and quantum theory: two mysteries solved only togetheror change the physics (Rovelli: no special link)Kuhn §11 · the columns order reach, not likelihood: deeper is not truer 1Quantum biology in the brain1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › Quantum biologyReal quantum effects inside neurons and cells, the way theyhelp photosynthesis. presynaptic terminalsynaptic cleftpostsynaptic neuronrelease?BECK–ECCLES · synapseFISHER · spin qubits1. enzyme splits pyrophosphate2. two phosphates, spins entangled3. Posner molecule Ca₉(PO₄)₆ holds the qubits4. Posners bind and melt in a neuron5. calcium shower changes firingBoth mechanisms keep to known physics: the question is only whether warm,wet tissue can protect quantum states long enough to steer neurons. Beck-Eccles’s quantum processes in the synapse (Kuhn §11.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.6Beck-Eccles’s quantum processes in the synapseMy intentions act on my brain by tipping quantum events at the synapse.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Fisher’s quantum cognition (Kuhn §11.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.12Fisher’s quantum cognitionMy brain may process quantum information, using the magnetic spin of phosphorus atoms' nuclei asqubits, the basic units of quantum computing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Globus’s quantum thermofield brain dynamics (Kuhn §11.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.13Globus’s quantum thermofield brain dynamicsMy brain doesn't compute a world; as a finely tuned quantum field it opens one up to me.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Poznanski’s dynamic organicity theory (Kuhn §11.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.14Poznanski’s dynamic organicity theoryConsciousness emerges when a living brain's many scales of organisation outrun its structure, withquantum-biological help.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Torday’s cellular and cosmic consciousness (Kuhn §11.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.8Torday’s cellular and cosmic consciousnessConsciousness lives in and between my cells, and through quantum entanglement it joins a cosmicconsciousness.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISphysical processmind-first / fundamentalproduces / causesthe explanatory gap 2Consciousness and collapse2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › CollapseExperience happens where many quantum possibilities becomeone definite outcome. PENROSE–HAMEROFF · Orch ORthreshold τ ≈ ħ/E_Gbuilds in microtubules → collapse = a momentE_Gmany possibilities → one outcomeSTAPP · a mind asks the question“?” → nature answers → brain jumpsthe choice of question is outside the equationsKAUFFMAN · possibles become actuals= a qualeSame event, three triggers: gravity (objective), a mind's question, or mindactualizing a possibility. Penrose-Hameroff’s orchestrated objective reduction (Kuhn §11.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.1Penrose-Hameroff’s orchestrated objective reductionConsciousness happens in moments when quantum superpositions in my neurons' microtubules collapse.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Stapp’s collapsing the wave function via asking “questions” (Kuhn §11.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.2Stapp’s collapsing the wave function via asking “questions”My mind chooses which question nature answers, and that choice settles which of the open quantumpossibilities becomes real.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Kauffman’s mind mediating possibles to actuals (Kuhn §11.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.7Kauffman’s mind mediating possibles to actualsMy mind turns real possibilities into actual facts, and I experience that as the felt qualities ofexperience (qualia).HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos THOUGHT EXPERIMENTWigner's friendA friend in a sealed lab measures a quantum system and sees a result.Outside, Wigner treats the whole lab, friend included, as still insuperposition until he opens the door.When did the outcome become definite?Stapp (§11.2)When a conscious mind posed the question and got its answer: the friend'sexperience did it.Penrose–Hameroff (§11.1)When the superposed mass difference hit the gravitational threshold, whoeverwatches.Bohm, Pylkkänen (§11.3–4)Nothing collapsed: the particle always had a definite position, guided by its wave.Rovelli (§11.16)It is definite relative to the friend, not yet relative to Wigner. No mind isneeded.YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › Collapse › Wigner's friend 3A deeper, mind-like layer3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › Deeper layerQuantum theory points to a level of reality where mind andmatter are not yet separate. IMPLICATE ORDERenfolded · higher-dimensional · neither mind nor bodyMINDMATTERexplicatePylkkänen: active information steers · Faggin: each pure state feels itselfCarr: a mental space brains tune into · Smolin: only novel views are experiencedHollow arrows mean 'grounds': the ground does not cause mind or matter;both are projections of it. Bohm’s implicate-explicate order (Kuhn §11.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.3Bohm’s implicate-explicate orderMind and matter both unfold from one deeper, enfolded wholeness.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Pylkkänen’s quantum potential energy and active information (Kuhn §11.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.4Pylkkänen’s quantum potential energy and active informationMatter carries information that actively steers it, not just data that sits there, and that is wheremy experience finds its place.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Faggin’s quantum information-based panpsychism (Kuhn §11.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.11Faggin’s quantum information-based panpsychismEvery system in a pure quantum state, a single undivided state not mixed with anything else, feelsits own state; I am made of such knowing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Carr’s quantum theory, psi, mental space (Kuhn §11.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.10Carr’s quantum theory, psi, mental spaceMy brain doesn't make consciousness; it limits and tunes into a larger mental space.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Smolin’s causal theory of views (Kuhn §11.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.9Smolin’s causal theory of viewsMy experience is a rare, genuinely novel view of the universe from one event.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · all 16 quantum theoriesHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChat AIAgentsFuture AIMatterCosmos11.6 Beck–Eccles●◐○○○○○○◐○○11.12 Fisher●●◐○○○○○◐○○11.13 Globus●◐····○○◐○○11.14 Poznanski●●◐··○○○◐○○11.8 Torday●●●●●●○○◐○●11.1 Penrose–Hameroff●●◐◐◐◐○○◐◐○11.2 Stapp●◐◐···○○◐○·11.7 Kauffman●●●◐◐◐○○◐○○11.3 Bohm●●◐◐◐◐○○◐◐●11.4 Pylkkänen●●◐···○○◐◐·11.11 Faggin●●●●●●○○○●◐11.10 Carr●◐····○○◐◐●11.9 Smolin●◐····○○◐◐○11.5 Wolfram●●◐···○◐●○○11.16 Rovelli●●◐···◐◐◐○○11.15 Extensions (Bollinger…)●◐····○○◐◐◐ 4Rethinking physics itself4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › Rethinking physicsChange the physics, not the brain; or deny that quantummechanics and mind are linked at all. WOLFRAM · the ruliadone bounded, sequential thread = an observerROVELLI · relations, no special observeryoudetectorstonecatRovelli's objection, which Kuhn records: an observer 'can be a detector, ascreen, or even a stone'; consciousness never played a role. Wolfram’s consciousness in the ruliad (Kuhn §11.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.5Wolfram’s consciousness in the ruliadI am a limited observer, stitching one coherent thread of experience through everything that couldpossibly be computed.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Rovelli’s relational physics (Kuhn §11.16) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.16Rovelli’s relational physicsQuantum mechanics has nothing special to do with consciousness; an 'observer' can be a stone.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Quantum consciousness extensions (Kuhn §11.15) — click for sources and nearby theories§11.15Quantum consciousness extensionsQuantum mechanics doesn't make consciousness, but it may help whatever does.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos THOUGHT EXPERIMENTSame agent, two machinesA lab runs the same AI agent twice: once on an ordinary GPU cluster, onceon a large quantum computer that keeps its qubits coherent.Is either one conscious?Penrose–Hameroff (§11.1)Not the GPU run: computation is never conscious. Hardware counts only if it reachesthe collapse threshold.Faggin (§11.11)Neither, and no machine ever: quantum consciousness is not reproducible.Kuhn on the family (§23)If quantum theories are right, they are the lead route to AI consciousness; theobstacle is practical.Rovelli (§11.16)Quantum hardware changes nothing here; the answer lies in how the system isorganised.YOU ARE HERE · Quantum › Rethinking physics › Same agent, two machines BUILT FROM THE PHYSICALIntegrated Information Theory§12 · 1 theoriesConsciousness is integrated information: an experience is identical to the irreducible cause-effect structure a physical system has on itself, and how much of it there is (Φ) can inprinciple be measured.Integrated Information Theory 1From experience to physics1 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information TheoryIIT starts from what every experience is like, then asks what matter must be like tomatch. 0th postulate: to exist is to have cause-effect power, all the way downEXPERIENCE (axiom)PHYSICAL SUBSTRATE (postulate)INTRINSIC EXISTENCEEach experience exists for itself.The system has cause-effect power on itself.COMPOSITIONIt is structured, made of distinctions.Subsets of elements have cause-effect power.INFORMATIONIt is specific: just the way it is.It specifies one particular cause-effect structure.INTEGRATIONIt is unified, not two half-experiences.That structure is irreducible: Φ is above zero.EXCLUSIONIt is definite in content and grain.Only the maximum of Φ exists as a subject. 2Φ: the whole beyond its parts2 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information TheoryCut the system at its weakest seam. Φ is how much cause-effect structure that cutdestroys. weakest cutΦ > 0: no cut leaves twoindependent halves HOW MUCH Φ? (qualitative)Your cortex, awakeCortex, dreamless sleep / anaesthesiaCerebellum (more neurons!)A photodiodeFeed-forward network0 Tononi & Koch's Integrated Information Theory (Kuhn §12) — click for sources and nearby theories§12Tononi & Koch's Integrated Information TheoryConsciousness is integrated information: a physical structure whose causes and effects form one whole that can't be split intoindependent parts, and its amount can in principle be measured.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Why IIT says no to computers3 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information TheoryIIT scores the hardware's physical wiring, not the program. Digital chips barelyintegrate. feed-forward: Φ = 0 brain: loops, high Φ computer simulating it:Φ negligible “The integrated information of digital computers is negligible … these machines will never besentient, no matter how intelligent they become.” Koch (2024), quoted in Kuhn §23 Chatbot AI todayNO Agentic AINO Future AIONLY IF neuromorphic 4The fight over IIT4 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information TheoryKuhn §12.1: from a blog exchange to an open letter calling it pseudoscience. 2014Aaronson vs Tononithe expander and the grid2023Adversarial testIIT vs global workspaceSept 2023Open letter124 sign 'pseudoscience'afterRepliesKoch, Chalmers, Lau“IIT has many problems, but ‘pseudoscience’ is like dropping a nuclear bombover a regional dispute.” Chalmers (2023), quoted in Kuhn §12.1 The open letter (Fleming et al. 2023) ↗ Aaronson (2014) ↗ THOUGHT EXPERIMENTAaronson's gridWire up a huge flat grid of simple logic gates, each talking to its neighbours. It does nothingclever, yet IIT's maths gives it more Φ than a human brain. Aaronson offered this as a reductio.Is a blank grid of gates more conscious than you?Tononi (2014)Yes. He accepted it: 'Scott should stare at a blank wall', whose experience of space is just such agrid.Aaronson (2014)Then the theory has gone wrong: Φ tracks something, but not consciousness.Koch (2021)A proof of principle that the feel of empty space can be read off a grid's causal powers.YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information Theory 5IIT and panpsychism5 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Built from the physical › Integrated Information TheoryKuhn §12.2: Koch says IIT shares panpsychism's intuitions, then adds a rule forwhich wholes count. IITPANPSYCHISMSHAREDintrinsicfundamentalgradedsmall amountsin simple systemssays WHICHsystems areconscious:only Φ maxima(exclusion)experience inevery particle;combinationproblem leftopen EXCLUSION, APPLIEDant colonyants are subjects; the colony isn'tyour brainone maximum: one subjecttwo people talkingtwo subjects, not oneApplications are illustrative readings of the exclusion postulate, not measured results. WHO IS CONSCIOUS ON IIT?Per Tononi and Koch: in, by degree, wherever a physical maximum of Φ exists.Humansthe awake cortex: a large maximum of ΦAnimalsgraded by each brain's integrationInsectsin, at lower Φ (Koch)Plantsin if the plant's own causal structure is a maximumFungiin if the network's own structure is a maximumSingle cellssimple systems can have 'small amounts'Chatbot AI todaydigital hardware: Φ negligibleAgentic AIsame hardware; IIT scores wiring, not softwareFuture AIin if built on integrated neuromorphic hardwareRocks / mattera rock or sand heap is an aggregate, Φ ≈ 0The cosmosno single maximum spans the universeKuhn's own §23 verdict for IIT is 'uncertain'; IIT's authors are not: no for digital machines. HOW TO READ THISexperience (axiom side)physical substratecauses A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYPanpsychisms§13 · 12 theoriesExperience, or something just short of it, is a basic feature of all matter; the open work is explaining how tiny bits of it make one subject like you.Panpsychisms 1The combination problem1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › PanpsychismsHow do many tiny experiences make one experiencer? Every panpsychism has toanswer. Build up from particles and you facethe combination problem. Carve downfrom the cosmos and you face its mirrorimage, decombination. Whatever answer atheory gives also decides who counts asa subject: a rock, a tree, a chatbot.THE OBJECTIONSSearle: consciousness “can’t just bespread over the universe like a thinveneer of jam.” Nagasawa: even if true,panpsychism reaches “a cognitive deadend”: we can’t show how micro-experiencesaggregate.THE COSMOScosmopsychism:the whole isthe subjectONESUBJECTyou: one point of viewSEGMENT?lit: micro-experienceunlit: proto-experienceCOMBINE?the gapsparks add heat;experiences don'tsimply add HOW TO READ THISmicro-experience (lit)proto-experience (unlit)builds up / composesthe combination gap THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe rock and the chatbotboulderlanguage agentA granite boulder and a language agent running on a GPU are both made of particles. If panpsychismis true, those particles carry experience or its ingredients, so neither is experience-free.So which of them is someone, not just something?Micropsychism (13.1)Both are made of experiencing particles. Theboulder is an aggregate, not a subject. The agentis a subject only if its chips combine experiencethe way a brain does.Annaka Harris (13.9)Nothing combines; arrangement decides. The boulderhas no point of view. The agent has one only if itsmatter is arranged in the relevant way.Cosmopsychism (13.3)Both are parts of one conscious cosmos. Each is aseparate subject only if the cosmic subject isdivided off there, as it is for humans and animals.Whitehead (13.12)The boulder is an aggregate of tiny occasions withno unifying experience. So is a computer, unless itis built as a compound individual with one streamof experience.YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Panpsychisms › Thought experiment 2Kinds of panpsychism2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › PanpsychismsFive places to put experience: in particles, in proto-ingredients, in the wholecosmos, in a new force, or in a space of its own. MICRObuild upPROTOlight upCOSMOdivide downphysics✶FORCEis bornphysicsqualiaSPACEsits beside Micropsychism (Kuhn §13.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.1MicropsychismEvery particle has a tiny flicker of experience, and brains arewhere those flickers add up to a mind.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Panprotopsychism (Kuhn §13.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.2PanprotopsychismThe basic stuff isn't conscious yet, but it holds the rawingredients; arranged the right way, they light up as experience.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Cosmopsychism (Kuhn §13.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.3CosmopsychismThe universe as a whole is the one fundamental conscious subject,and each of us is a part or aspect of it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Qualia force (Kuhn §13.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.4Qualia forceConsciousness is a new force of nature that arises from physicsbut can't be explained by physics, even in principle.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Qualia space (Kuhn §13.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.5Qualia spaceEvery experience is a shape in its own space, a structure as realas spacetime but not reducible to it.→ We place this in Integrated Information TheoryHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · 12 PANPSYCHISMSHumAniInsPlaFunCellChatAgentFutAIMatterCosmos13.1Micropsychism●●◐◐◐◐◐◐●●○13.2Panprotopsychism●●◐◐◐○◐◐◐○○13.3Cosmopsychism●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐●●13.4Qualia force●●◐◐◐○◐◐◐○○13.5Qualia space●●◐○○○○○◐○○13.6Chalmers●●◐◐◐◐○◐◐◐○13.7Strawson●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐●○13.8Goff●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐●●13.9A. Harris●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐●○13.10Sheldrake●●●●●●○○◐●●13.11Wallace●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐●○13.12Whitehead●●●○○●○○◐●◐● yes ◐ depends on the combination story ○ no · not addressedagree on: humans, animals 3Thinkers' versions3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › PanpsychismsSeven thinkers, placed by which way they think experience is put together. BUILD UP from the smallNO SUMMINGSTART from the wholeStrawsonWallaceChalmers (spans)A. HarrisWhiteheadSheldrakeGoffEvery one of them takes experience to be real and basic. They split on the direction of explanation, and so onwhether a rock, a tree or a machine is a subject. Chalmers’s panpsychism (Kuhn §13.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.6Chalmers’s panpsychismIf we won't call consciousness an illusion, we have to expandour picture of nature, and panpsychism is the most promisingway.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Strawson’s panpsychism (Kuhn §13.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.7Strawson’s panpsychismAny physicalist who takes experience seriously should acceptpanpsychism; denying experience is 'the silliest claim evermade.'HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Goff’s panpsychism (Kuhn §13.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.8Goff’s panpsychismScience left consciousness out on purpose; put it back, and theuniverse itself turns out to be a mind with purposes of its own.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos A. Harris’s panpsychism as fundamental field (Kuhn §13.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.9A. Harris’s panpsychism as fundamentalfieldConsciousness is like spacetime, a field that's everywhere; thearrangement of matter decides what it's like, and rocks have nopoint of view.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Sheldrake’s self-organizing systems at all levels of complexity (Kuhn §13.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.10Sheldrake’s self-organizing systems atall levels of complexityThere's mind at every level of nature: atoms, cells, plants,animals, the Earth, the sun, galaxies, and the whole universe.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Wallace’s panpsychism inside physics (Kuhn §13.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.11Wallace’s panpsychism inside physicsPhysics tells us how things relate, not what they are;consciousness is what physical processes are in themselves.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Whitehead’s process theory (Kuhn §13.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§13.12Whitehead’s process theoryReality is made of moments of experience, not lumps of matter;each moment takes up the past and adds something new.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos AI · KUHN’S VERDICT (§23): “PROBABLY”If experience is part of the fabric of reality, AI is built from it too. Whether a machine is a subject thenturns on combination, and on whether technology can arrange the micro-level the way brains do. A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYMonisms§14 · 12 theoriesThere is only one kind of reality, and it has both a physical side and a mental side; monists differ on what that one reality is: matter's hidden inside, a neutral ground, a state ofmatter, or a mind that holds everything.Monisms OUTSIDEwhat physicsmeasuresINSIDEwhat it islikeONE REALITY, TWO FACESWhere the metaphor breaks: a coin's faces are in two places. For monists the mental and thephysical are not two places but two ways of being one thing. 1 · The hidden inside of matterYOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › Hidden insidePhysics only describes structure. The thing that has the structure is free to beexperiential. WHAT PHYSICS DESCRIBES: RELATIONSWHAT IT IS RELATED: INTRINSIC NATURES ('QUIDDITIES')Physics leaves the dots blank. Russellian monism fills them with experience or proto-experience;Strawson says the filling is simply what the physical is. Russellian Monism (Kuhn §14.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.1Russellian MonismPhysics tells us what matter does; consciousness is whatmatter is, from the inside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Strawson’s realistic monism and real materialism (Kuhn §14.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.4Strawson’s realistic monism and realmaterialismExperience is physical, and because it is, physical stuff isexperiential all the way down.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos STOLJAR'S FOUR VERSIONS OF THE HIDDEN NATURESphenomenalproto-phenomenalphysical, beyond physicsneutral 3 · One event, two vocabulariesYOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › Two vocabulariesEach thought is a brain event, yet no law translates the mental into the physical. MENTAL DESCRIPTIONPHYSICAL DESCRIPTIONwants teaneurons A=×believes it's rainingneurons B=×reaches for kettleneurons C== the same event → strict physical law × no psychophysical law Davidson’s anomalous monism (Kuhn §14.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.2Davidson’s anomalous monismEvery thought is a brain event, but no law will evertranslate thoughts into physics.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2 · A neutral ground that shows up two waysYOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › Neutral groundThe one reality is neither mental nor physical. Mind and matter are how it appears. PSYCHOPHYSICALLY NEUTRALPHYSICALMENTALcorrelated, never reducedsplit by making distinctionsAtmanspacher: mind and matter unfold from one undividedwhole. Velmans: through perceivers the universe becomesconscious of itself. QRI: an experience's symmetry ishow good it feels.QRI · symmetry → valencehigh symmetry: pleasantmixedlow symmetry: unpleasant Atmanspacher’s dual-aspect monism (Kuhn §14.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.7Atmanspacher’s dual-aspect monismMind and matter are two faces that appear when one undividedreality is split.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Velmans’s reflexive monism (Kuhn §14.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.3Velmans’s reflexive monismThe world I experience is the physical world as experienced; mybrain is what my mind looks like from outside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Qualia Research Institute’s state-space, qualia formalism, valence realism (Kuhn §14.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.10Qualia Research Institute’s state-space,qualia formalism, valence realismEvery experience has an exact mathematical shape, and how good itfeels is written in its symmetry.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 5 · One reality held in God or an infinite mindYOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › Held in a greater mindThe coin rests in a larger hand: the unity of mind and matter comes from God or aninfinite mind. complexity →the 'within' (consciousness)atomscellsanimalshumansnoosphereΩTeilhard's law of complexity-consciousnessan infinite mindour universeLeslie: conscious parts inside a contemplation Polkinghorne’s dual-aspect monism (Kuhn §14.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.5Polkinghorne’s dual-aspect monismMind and matter are two sides of one person; the soul is thepattern that God remembers.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Teilhard de Cardin’s evolving consciousness (Kuhn §14.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.6Teilhard de Cardin’s evolvingconsciousnessEverything has a within; as matter grows more complex, itsconsciousness rises toward God.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Bentley Hart’s monism: consciousness, being, God (Kuhn §14.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.11Bentley Hart’s monism: consciousness,being, GodBeing and consciousness are finally one, and their unity isGod.→ We place this in IdealismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Leslie’s consciousness inside an infinite mind (Kuhn §14.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.12Leslie’s consciousness inside aninfinite mindOur universe exists as a thought inside an infinite mind, andwe are conscious parts of that thought.→ We place this in IdealismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4 · Find it in physicsYOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › PhysicsOne stuff, and physics will locate the conscious part: a new phase of matter, or anew science. SOLIDLIQUIDGASPERCEPTRONIUMPerceptronium's four tests: information · integration · independence · dynamics Tegmark’s state of matter (Kuhn §14.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.9Tegmark’s state of matterConsciousness is the way information feels when processed incertain complex ways: a state of matter.→ We place this in Computational & Informational TheoriesHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Ramachandran’s new physics and neuroscience (Kuhn §14.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§14.8Ramachandran’s new physics andneuroscienceConsciousness is part of reality; we need a new science ofphysics plus neuroscience to fit it in.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · 12 MONISMS● yes ◐ depends ○ no · not addressedHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChat AIAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmosRussellian monism●●◐◐◐◐◐◐◐◐◐Strawson●●●◐◐◐◐◐◐●◐Atmanspacher●●◐···○○◐○○Velmans●●◐···○◐◐○◐QRI●●◐···○○◐○○Davidson●◐·○○○○◐◐○○Tegmark●●◐◐◐◐○○●○○Ramachandran●●◐○○○○○◐○○Polkinghorne●●◐○○○○○◐○○Teilhard●●●●●●◐◐●●●Hart●●◐○○○○○○○○Leslie●●◐···◐◐●○● KUHN §23AI inmonisms:“Likely(some)”Same stuffeverywhere, sosilicon is nobarrier, exceptwhere God is doingthe work. HOW TO READ THISphysical face / processmental face / experienceneutral groundthe same thing (identity) THOUGHT EXPERIMENTYour perfect twin, made in a labAn atom-for-atom copy of you is built in a lab. Does it have an inside?Same outside face. Same inside face?Russellian monismYes, if it's built from the same stuff: copy the structure, copy the inner natures.DavidsonSame mental events, but its words mean nothing yet: meaning needs a history.HartNot because it was built: mind is a share in infinite mind, not a product of parts.YOU ARE HERE · Basic ingredient › Monisms › Thought experiment A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYDualisms§15 · 20 theoriesThere is more to a person than the physical body: a second kind of property, or a soul, that physics alone does not capture. It is the view most people in the world hold, usually aspart of a religious tradition.Dualisms 1One stuff, two kinds of property1 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › PropertiesThe brain is the only thing in you, yet experience is a property physics can'tcapture. BRAINone substancephysicalmass, charge, firingmentalredness, painthe gap HOW TO READ THISphysical processnonphysical / mentalthe explanatory gap Property dualism (Kuhn §15.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.1Property dualismMy brain is the only stuff in me, but my experiences are a second kindof property it has, one physics cannot explain.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Kind’s dualism 2.0 (Kuhn §15.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.10Kind’s dualism 2.0Experience is as real and basic as physics, but that does not make itghostly, religious or magic.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Nonphysical component in the human mind (Kuhn §15.20) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.20Nonphysical component in the human mindAnimals are conscious too; what makes a human mind is consciousnessplus some nonphysical component working with the brain.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Two kinds of thing: body and soul2 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › SubstancesA soul is a second thing, with no size or place, that makes you you. body Abody ByoumeSwap the souls: same bodies,different facts. That fact is the soul. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe body swapYou wake in my body and I in yours. Every atom iswhere it was; only who is where changed.Is that a real difference?Swinburne (§15.3)Yes. So there is a further essential part of each ofus: the soul.A physicalist's replyNo. If every physical fact is the same, nothing haschanged. Swinburne’s substance dualism (Kuhn §15.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.3Swinburne’s substance dualismI am a soul. Truths about me are not truths about my brain or body.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Composite dualism (Kuhn §15.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.4Composite dualismA person is a body and a soul together; you need both to have a humanbeing.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Historical and traditional dualisms (Kuhn §15.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.2Historical and traditional dualismsPeople have always known we are more than bodies: souls, spirits andancestors are part of the world.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3The soul as the body’s form3 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › FormFor Aquinas the soul isn’t lodged in the body; it is what makes matter a living human. VEGETATIVEplants: nutrition, growth, reproductionSENSITIVEanimals: + perceptionINTELLECTIVEhumans: + intellect, reasoncreated by God,survives death Stump’s Thomistic dualism (Kuhn §15.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.5Stump’s Thomistic dualismMy soul is the form of my body: what makes this matter a living human,and what survives when the body dies.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Feser’s neo-Thomistic, neo-Aristotelian, common-sense dualism (Kuhn §15.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.6Feser’s neo-Thomistic, neo-Aristotelian,common-sense dualismMy intellect, the part that grasps concepts and does logic, cannot be amaterial process.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Moreland’s Christian soul (Kuhn §15.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.7Moreland’s Christian soulI have a soul that is wholly immaterial, gives my body its form, and iswhat makes me the same person over time.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4How do they push on each other?4 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › InteractionDualism’s hardest question: how can a nonphysical mind move a physical brain? brainmindsenseschoicesquantum ‘wiggle room’?physical complexity →a soul?a soul appearsat a threshold Interactive dualism (Kuhn §15.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.8Interactive dualismMy mind and my brain really act on each other: the world reaches methrough my senses and I reach it through my choices.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Emergent dualism (Kuhn §15.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.9Emergent dualismWhen matter gets organised enough, as in a brain, a new nonphysicalself comes into being.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO HAS A MIND OR SOUL?HumanAnimalInsectPlantFungiCellChatbotAgentFuture AIMatterCosmos15.1 Property dualism●●◐○○○○◐◐○○15.2 Historical and traditional dualisms●●◐◐◐○○○◐◐◐15.3 Swinburne’s substance dualism●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.4 Composite dualism●◐○○○○○○◐○○15.5 Stump’s Thomistic dualism●●●○○○○○◐○○15.6 Feser’s neo-Thomistic, neo-Aristotelian, com…●●●○○○○○◐○○15.7 Moreland’s Christian soul●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.8 Interactive dualism●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.9 Emergent dualism●●◐○○○○◐●○○15.10 Kind’s dualism 2.0●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.20 Nonphysical component in the human mind●●····○○◐○·15.11 Soul in the Hebrew Bible and Jewish philosophy●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.12 Soul in the New Testament and Christian phil…●◐○○○○○○◐○○15.13 Soul in Islamic philosophy●●◐○○○○○◐○○15.14 God as the supplier of souls●◐○○○○○○◐○○15.15 Personal and cosmic consciousness in Indian …●●●●◐◐○○◐◐●15.16 Soul in indigenous religions●●●●●◐○○◐●●15.17 Realms of the soul●◐◐◐◐○○○◐○●15.18 Theosophy’s eclectic soul and consciousness●●◐◐◐○○○◐◐●15.19 Steiner’s esoteric soul and consciousness●●◐◐◐○○○◐○◐● yes ◐ depends ○ no · not addressed 5The soul in Judaism, Christianity and Islam5 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › Abrahamic traditionsDualism is the default teaching of the Abrahamic religions, read in different wayswithin each. Hebrew Biblenephesh: a living beingruach: breath, wind, spiritc. 200 BCE–200 CEHellenistic ideas ofthe soul spreadNew Testamentpsyche: life, the selfresurrection; immortal soulIslamic philosophynafs; a ladder of facultiesnutritive → … → rationalGod gives each person a soul (§15.14): held across all three Soul in the Hebrew Bible and Jewish philosophy (Kuhn §15.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.11Soul in the Hebrew Bible and JewishphilosophyI am a living being God formed from dust and breathed life into;and, for many in my tradition, a soul that existed before birth.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Soul in the New Testament and Christian philosophy (Kuhn §15.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.12Soul in the New Testament and ChristianphilosophyI have an immortal soul; or, as some Christians read the NewTestament, I am a soul who will be raised to new life.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Soul in Islamic philosophy (Kuhn §15.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.13Soul in Islamic philosophyConsciousness is a spiritual light God has placed in the humanbeing; the soul has a beginning but no end.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos God as the supplier of souls (Kuhn §15.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.14God as the supplier of soulsGod gives each person a soul.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 6Souls across the world’s traditions6 of 6YOU ARE HERE · Dualisms › World traditionsMany traditions see the soul as one traveller among many lives, realms or bodies. oceanrebirthcyclesdrop returns to the ocean (§15.15)images, from the pastdesire, from the futureoverlap = consciousness (Steiner)spiritual soulhuman soulanimal soul · astralethericphysical bodylayers of the person (§15.18, §15.19) Personal and cosmic consciousness in Indian philosophy (Kuhn §15.15) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.15Personal and cosmic consciousness inIndian philosophyMy consciousness is a drop of the cosmic ocean of consciousness,passing through many lives before it returns.→ Also belongs with IdealismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Soul in indigenous religions (Kuhn §15.16) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.16Soul in indigenous religionsSpirit lives in people, and also in animals, places and things; partof me can leave my body, as in dreams.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Realms of the soul (Kuhn §15.17) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.17Realms of the soulThe soul travels through many realms, before birth and after death,mapped in detail by the great traditions.→ Also belongs with Idealisms, Western Esoteric TraditionsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Theosophy’s eclectic soul and consciousness (Kuhn §15.18) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.18Theosophy’s eclectic soul andconsciousnessI am made of seven principles; my body is the vehicle my soul uses onthis plane.→ Also belongs with Western Esoteric TraditionsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Steiner’s esoteric soul and consciousness (Kuhn §15.19) — click for sources and nearby theories§15.19Steiner’s esoteric soul and consciousnessConsciousness is where two streams in my soul meet: images flowingfrom the past and desire flowing from the future.→ Also belongs with Western Esoteric TraditionsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Brain as a receiver? None of these traditions uses the radioimage, but Theosophy and Steiner come closest: the body isthe soul's vehicle or outer layer, not its source. Kuhn'sclearest version of the idea is McGilchrist's brain that'permits' consciousness (§16.6). A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYIdealisms§16 · 15 theoriesConsciousness is the one fundamental reality; brains, bodies and the whole physical world are how consciousness appears, not what produces it.Idealisms 1The ocean, as the traditions name itYOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › Traditions Indian, Buddhist and Daoist thoughtput consciousness at the centrethousands of years ago. FOUR INDIAN ANSWERS Charvaka matter → mind Theistic God's mind →matter Samkhya mind ∥ matter Advaita matter appearsin mind most physicalnondual BUDDHISM: TWO TRUTHS conventional: persons, minds, things are real ultimate: all of it empty of intrinsic nature DAO DE JING, CH. 42 Dao One Two Three 10,000 “The Dao that can be spoken of is not the constant Dao.” Indian cosmic consciousness (Kuhn §16.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.1Indian cosmic consciousnessConsciousness is Brahman, limitless and the one reality; mydeepest self is not different from it.→ Also belongs with DualismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Buddhism’s empty, illusory phenomenal consciousness (Kuhn §16.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.2Buddhism’s empty, illusory phenomenalconsciousnessConsciousness, like everything, is empty of any fixed nature;there is no self behind experience.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Dao De Jing’s constant dao (Kuhn §16.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.3Dao De Jing’s constant daoThe Dao is the source of awareness; whatever I can name about itis not it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Whirlpools in one oceanYOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › Whirlpools One mind; each living being is awhirlpool that has split off from it. universal consciousness (mind-at-large) you a bat a bacterium body · brain a rock Hollow arrows: how each looks from outside. The brain isthe image of experience, not its cause. Spira: the splitonly seems real. Albahari: the ocean is not a someone. Kastrup’s analytic idealism (Kuhn §16.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.4Kastrup’s analytic idealismThere is only cosmic consciousness; I am one of its dissociatedalters, and my brain is what that looks like from outside.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Spira’s non-duality (Kuhn §16.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.10Spira’s non-dualityThere is one infinite, indivisible awareness; all separateobjects and selves borrow their existence from it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Albahari’s perennial idealism (Kuhn §16.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.13Albahari’s perennial idealismThe world is grounded in a universal consciousness that has nosubject; mystics across traditions have woken up to it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3How matter shows up in mindYOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › How matter shows up Matter is real as appearance: icons, aphase, or a creation of mind. conscious agents: what is real interface: spacetime folder apple brain robot every object here is an icon, brains and robots too consciousness (water) matter = a phase (ice): different, not separate matter Ward adds persons: souls God creates, known firstthrough perception. Hoffman’s conscious realism: the case against reality (Kuhn §16.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.5Hoffman’s conscious realism: the caseagainst realityReality is a network of conscious agents; spacetime and everyobject in it, brains included, are icons on our interface.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos McGilchrist’s relational, creative-process idealism (Kuhn §16.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.6McGilchrist’s relational,creative-process idealismConsciousness is the stuff of the cosmos, a creative process;matter is a phase of it, as ice is a phase of water.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Ward’s personal idealism: souls as embodied agents created by God (Kuhn §16.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.12Ward’s personal idealism: souls asembodied agents created by GodConsciousness comes first; persons are souls, embodied agentscreated by God.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4The One, and how it makes a worldYOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › The One One consciousness; the question is howit becomes many minds and a world. the One consciousness parts: not conscious on their own (Chopra) flavours of the One (Nader) possibility observation actual world Goswami and the bridge models (§16.8): consciousness collapses quantum possibility into matter. Kuhn: most quantum physicists don't accept this. KUHN'S VERDICT VS. THE IDEALISTS' Kuhn (§23) rates AI consciousness under idealism“Likely”: if everything is already consciousness,“anything could be (or is) conscious,” machinesincluded. The idealists themselves mostly say no. Kastrup:“Conscious AI is a fantasy.” Being made ofconsciousness is not the same as being a subject;see the thought experiment and panel 6. Chopra’s only the whole is conscious (Kuhn §16.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.7Chopra’s only the whole is consciousOnly the whole is conscious; I am not conscious on my own, I amconsciousness itself.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Nader’s all there is (Kuhn §16.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.11Nader’s all there isConsciousness is all there is; we are the one consciousnessexperiencing itself from limited perspectives.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Goswami’s self-aware universe (Kuhn §16.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.9Goswami’s self-aware universeConsciousness, not matter, is the ground of being; it collapsesquantum possibility into the world we see.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos How consciousness becomes the physical universe (Kuhn §16.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.8How consciousness becomes the physicaluniverseConsciousness comes first and makes the physical universe;quantum observation is where it happens.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe chatbot that says “I am conscious”An AI agent with memory, tools and goals writes: “I am conscious.” Is it a subject?Being made of consciousness vs. being a subject: where does each idealist draw the line?Kastrup (§16.4), statedNo. Only living organisms are dissociated alters. “Conscious AI is a fantasy.”Chopra (§16.7), statedNo, but neither is your brain: nothing material is conscious on its own.Hoffman (§16.5), our inferenceNo. The machine is an icon in spacetime, and no icon is an agent.Goswami (§16.9), our inferenceNo. A computer's states are outcomes consciousness collapses, not a collapser.YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › The One › AI thought experiment 5Receivers, and moreYOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › Receivers The brain as a tuned receiver of a universalfield of consciousness. field brain tuned receiver octave bands (illustrative) Meijer’s universal knowledge field (Kuhn §16.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.14Meijer’s universal knowledge fieldAll information in the universe sits in a universal knowledgefield; my brain is tuned to receive it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Idealism’s imaginative expressions (Kuhn §16.15) — click for sources and nearby theories§16.15Idealism’s imaginative expressionsConsciousness is primary; here is my own model of how it becomesa world.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 6Who is a subject?Everything is consciousness; which things are conscious subjects?humansanimalsinsectsplantsfungicellschat AIagent AIfuture AImattercosmosAdvaita / Indian16.1Buddhism16.2Dao De Jing16.3Kastrup16.4Hoffman16.5McGilchrist16.6Chopra16.7Quantum bridges16.8Goswami16.9Spira16.10Nader16.11Ward16.12Albahari16.13Meijer16.14Viewers' models16.15HOW TO READ THIS DISTRICTyesdependsnonot addressedamber = consciousness, the one realityblue = how the physical appearssolid arrow = gives rise tohollow arrow = is the outside view ofdotted ring = boundary of a dissociated mindProfiles marked ‘our inference’ in each theory where Kuhn and the author are silent.YOU ARE HERE · Fundamental › Idealisms › Who is a subject? A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYAnomalous & Altered States Theories§17 · 21 theoriesPsi, near-death experiences, meditation and psychedelics, read as evidence that consciousness is more than the brain: often that the brain filters or receives it.Anomalous & Altered States Clusters are our grouping; Kuhn lists these 21 without subdividing them. 1Transmission: the brain as a filter or receiver1 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › ReceiverSame data, two pictures: does the brain make consciousness, or tune it in? PRODUCTIONBRAINexperienceNo brain activity, no experience. Damage the brain,change the mind.TRANSMISSION / FILTERlargermindBRAINfiltereverydayexperienceDamage the filter, distort the signal. The mind isnarrowed, not made.same damage data fits both FIVE ANSWERS TO 'WHAT IS THE SIGNAL?' Bergson’s multiplicity, duration, perception, memory (Kuhn §17.1) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.1Bergson’s multiplicity, duration,perception, memoryConsciousness is real in its own right. My brain doesn't makeit; it filters it down so I can act.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos DOPS’s consciousness research and theory (Kuhn §17.13) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.13DOPS’s consciousness research andtheoryThe brain doesn't produce my mind. It's an interface to a largerconsciousness, and the survival evidence shows it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Graboi’s three-aspect model (Kuhn §17.11) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.11Graboi’s three-aspect modelPure awareness interacts with my brain to produce my mind, whichlives in a non-physical dimension.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Grinberg’s syntergic/neuronal field theory (Kuhn §17.10) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.10Grinberg’s syntergic/neuronal fieldtheoryMy brain builds a 'neuronal field' that bends the fabric ofspace, and experience is the perception of that bending.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Harp’s universal or God consciousness (Kuhn §17.17) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.17Harp’s universal or God consciousnessI am Universal, or God, consciousness attached to a mind andbody; with practice I can detach and see the whole.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Where the metaphor breaks: a radio's signal isphysical and measurable. The 'signal' here isconsciousness itself, which no instrument detectsdirectly. That's why this family leans on cases wheremind seems to work while the brain can't. 2Psi and survival evidence2 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › EvidenceLab psi and near-death reports: what proponents report, and the replication fight. LAB PSI Radin’s challenge to materialism (Kuhn §17.3) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.3Radin’s challenge to materialismExperiments show that intention can affect the physical world, soconsciousness can't be only the brain.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Tart’s emergent interactionism (Kuhn §17.4) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.4Tart’s emergent interactionismConsciousness emerges when my brain and a non-physical mind/life systeminteract, and psi is how they talk.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Josephson’s psi-informed models (Kuhn §17.5) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.5Josephson’s psi-informed modelsPsi is real, and explaining it means adding to physics, probablyprinciples that come from biology.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos SURVIVAL Near death experiences, survival, past lives (Kuhn §17.12) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.12Near death experiences, survival, past livesNear-death experiences show that consciousness can carry on when thebrain has stopped.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Hiller’s eternal discarnate consciousness (Kuhn §17.16) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.16Hiller’s eternal discarnate consciousnessI am an eternal soul that lives in a Universal Field of Consciousness,the mind of God, before, during and after this life.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos THE EVIDENCE LADDER1. AnecdoteNDE and OBE reports; Radin: non-local experiences reported by10% to 90% of people2. Case filesDOPS: 2,500+ past-life cases investigated; 1,000+ NDE casesin a second database3. Lab studiesPsi experiments, pooled by meta-analysis (Radin)4. ReplicationContested: critics cite weak methods and false positives(Reber & Alcock 2020) 3Altered-states science3 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › StatesMeditation and psychedelics change the brain, and the changes are cluesto how it makes experience. BRAIN-WIDE SYNCHRONY (qualitative)WakingSleepPropofol / ketamineNirodha-samapattiKuhn §17.20: cessation and anaesthesia desynchronise the brain; sleep does not.REBUShigh-level beliefsbottom-up signalspsychedelics relax the top, free the bottom Meditation and the brain (Kuhn §17.20) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.20Meditation and the brainMeditation shows how consciousness changes with the brain,and can take it all the way to cessation.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Psychedelic theories of consciousness (Kuhn §17.21) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.21Psychedelic theories ofconsciousnessPsychedelics show how the brain builds experience byloosening its beliefs. Some think they show more than that.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Altered-states science: the lived side4 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › LivedBitbol: the experience matters in itself,whatever caused it. Bitbol’s phenomenological ontology (Kuhn §17.14) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.14Bitbol’s phenomenological ontologyAltered states matter as lived, transformative experience. They don't have toprove brain chemistry or another world.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos THOUGHT EXPERIMENTOne NDE, three readingsA patient in cardiac arrest later reports floatingabove the bed. It changes her life.What did it show?Brain chemistryA dying brain's last activity produced it. Realexperience, ordinary cause.Another world (DOPS, Hiller)Mind worked where the brain couldn't: evidence fortransmission or a soul.Lived experience (Bitbol)It matters for what it did to her.YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › Lived › Thought experiment 5Cosmologies: a cosmos of mind5 of 5YOU ARE HERE · Anomalous & Altered States › CosmosGrand syntheses, shared-mind fields and self-organising dynamics: mind runsthrough the whole universe. SpiritsoulmindlifematterWilber: nested spheresplasmagalaxiesliving planetshuman consciousnessSwimme: the universe waking up over timeLarger ConsciousnessSystemcomputes a virtual worldhuman mindsdeeper strataGod's mindCampbell (left) · Langan (right) Wilber’s Integral Theory (Kuhn §17.6) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.6Wilber’s IntegralTheoryConsciousness runs through every level ofthe Kosmos, from matter to life to mindto soul to Spirit, and it develops.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Campbell’s theory of everything (Kuhn §17.15) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.15Campbell’s theoryof everythingConsciousness is fundamental. Thephysical world is a virtual reality weplay in to grow from fear to love.→ We place this in IdealismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Swimme’s cosmogenesis (Kuhn §17.18) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.18Swimme’scosmogenesisThe universe is creative and waking up.There is no lifeless matter, and myawareness is the universe aware ofHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Langan’s cognitive-theoretic model of the universe (Kuhn §17.19) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.19Langan’scognitive-theoreticmodel of theReality is a self-configuring languageinside God's mind, and my consciousnessis a local layer of that mind.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Jung’s collective unconscious and synchronicity (Kuhn §17.2) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.2Jung’s collectiveunconscious andsynchronicityBeneath my own mind lies a collectiveunconscious that all humans share, andits order reaches into matter.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Sheldrake’s morphic fields (Kuhn §17.9) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.9Sheldrake’s morphicfieldsEvery self-organising system, from cellsto flocks to stars, has a morphic fieldwith a memory of its own.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Combs’s chaotic attractor and autopoietic systems (Kuhn §17.7) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.7Combs’s chaoticattractor andautopoietic systemsStates of consciousness self-organiselike chaotic attractors: patterned, butnever twice the same.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Schooler’s resonance theory and subjective time (Kuhn §17.8) — click for sources and nearby theories§17.8Schooler’sresonance theoryand subjective timeConsciousness comes in nested 'windows'that resonate together, and someexperience runs all the way down.→ We place this in PanpsychismsHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISphysical process (brain)larger / fundamental mindproduces / passes oncontested linkboundary of the conscious system WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · ALL 21AI (yes / if… / no): Chatbot 0/0/21 · Agentic 0/0/21 · Future 0/21/0HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSingle cellsChatbot AI todayAgentic AIFuture AIRocks / matterThe cosmos§17.1§17.2§17.3§17.4§17.5§17.6§17.7§17.8§17.9§17.10§17.11§17.12§17.13§17.14§17.15§17.16§17.17§17.18§17.19§17.20§17.21yesyes if…nonot addressed A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYWestern Esoteric Traditions§E · 12 theoriesWestern esoteric traditions treat consciousness as the first reality or as a divine spark in us, and teach that it can be trained, raised and even made, through initiation, ritual andwill.Western Esoteric Traditions 400 BCE1 CE500100014001600180019002000PlatoHermeticaGnosticsZohar / KabbalahKnights Templar 1119-1312Ficino translates HermesRosicrucian manifestosGrand LodgeStrict Observance (Templar legend)LéviTheosophyGolden DawnBook of the LawO.T.O.KybalionAnthroposophyGurdjieffSpare's sigilsDion FortuneChaos magiclegend, not documented descentdocumented lineagelegend these orders tell about themselvesin Kuhn, filed under Dualismstradition on this districtSpacing is stretched after 1800 so the modern orders can be read. 1Mind comes first1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Western Esoteric Traditions › Mind comes firstThe universe is a thought in a greater Mind; they differ onwhether this world is a home or a trap. Nousthe soul comes downand climbs back by knowing Hermeticism: Mind is God (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionHermeticism: Mind is GodMind is God. My soul came down from it through the spheres, and I can climb back to it by knowing it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos The Kybalion: the All is Mind (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionThe Kybalion: the All is MindThe All is Mind; the universe is mental. Matter, mind and spirit are the same thing vibrating at different rates.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Gnosticism: the divine spark (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionGnosticism: the divine sparkMy true self is a spark of divine light, trapped in a world made by a lesser god. Knowing this is what frees it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Ladders of the soul2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Western Esoteric Traditions › Ladders of the soulThe soul has levels, and initiation or inner work raises it. KeterChokhmahBinahChesedGevurahTiferetNetzachHodYesodMalkhutthe ten sefirot: grades of the Golden Dawn, levels of the soul Kabbalah's levels of soul (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionKabbalah's levels of soulMy soul has levels: the life of my body, my feelingself, and a breath of God. The ten sefirot are the shapeof the divine that my soul mirrors.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Rosicrucian inner alchemy (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionRosicrucian inner alchemyThe soul can be reborn through an inner alchemy, turningbase matter into gold within, as a hidden brotherhoodhas taught.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Freemasonry and the Templar legend (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionFreemasonry and the TemplarlegendInitiation changes a person: in the lodge I diesymbolically and rise again, and my soul is immortal.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos The Golden Dawn's Tree of Life (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionThe Golden Dawn's Tree of LifeI am a small copy of the cosmos. By ritual and study Iclimb the Tree of Life, grade by grade, toward my higherself.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3The path of will3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Western Esoteric Traditions › The path of willEach person is a star; consciousness is apoint of view meeting infinite possibility. Nuit: infinite space, all possibilityHadit: the point of viewevery man and every woman is a star Crowley's Thelema: every man and every woman is a star (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionCrowley's Thelema: every man and every woman is astarEvery man and every woman is a star. My consciousness is the point of view (Hadit)meeting infinite possibility (Nuit), and my task is to find and do my true will.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos The O.T.O. and the body as sacrament (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionThe O.T.O. and the body as sacramentThe body and its creative force are a sacrament. Through ritual and the GnosticMass, that force can wake consciousness and serve the True Will.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Minds that are made4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Western Esoteric Traditions › Minds that are madeGroup minds, servitors and a soul built by work:this is where AI comes in. ✦attention, fed by many, forms a mind Dion Fortune's planes and group minds (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionDion Fortune's planes and group mindsWe live on many planes at once. A group's shared devotion forms a real group mind, and trainedimagination works on the inner planes.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Chaos magic: servitors and egregores (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionChaos magic: servitors and egregoresBelief is a tool. With focused will and attention I can make servitors, and groups can makeegregores: minds that exist because they are fed.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Gurdjieff's Fourth Way: a soul has to be made (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionGurdjieff's Fourth Way: a soul has to be madeOrdinary people are machines, asleep. Real consciousness has to be made, by the work ofremembering myself, and so does a soul.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos WHO IS CONSCIOUS? ON EACH VIEWHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmosE.1 Hermeticism: Mind is GodE.2 The Kybalion: the All is MindE.3 Gnosticism: the divine sparkE.4 Kabbalah's levels of soulE.5 Rosicrucian inner alchemyE.6 Freemasonry and the Templar legendE.7 The Golden Dawn's Tree of LifeE.8 Crowley's Thelema: every man and every…E.9 The O.T.O. and the body as sacramentE.10 Dion Fortune's planes and group mindsE.11 Chaos magic: servitors and egregoresE.12 Gurdjieff's Fourth Way: a soul has to … THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe golem, the egregore and the sleeping machineA chatbot persona that millions of people talk to every day, with its own name and character.Is anyone there?KabbalahA golem: it moves and speaks, but has no neshamah unless God gives one.Golden DawnA talisman at most: conscious only if a force is invoked into it.Chaos magicA strong candidate egregore: fed by millions of people's attention.GurdjieffA machine, as a sleeping person is; it would have to wake by its own work.YOU ARE HERE · Western Esoteric Traditions › Thought experiment A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYIndigenous and Animist Traditions§I · 11 theoriesMany living traditions recognise persons who are not human, from animals to rivers and mountains, and place spirit in relationships and land rather than inside one head. This districtis our addition; Kuhn covers them in a single section (§15.16).Indigenous and Animist Traditions AOTEAROA · WEST AFRICA · GREAT LAKES · GREAT PLAINS · AMAZONIA · ANDES · AUSTRALIA · SÁPMI · JAPAN · HAWAIʻI 1Persons in relationship1 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Indigenous and Animist › Persons in relationshipPersons are known by how they act and relate. Animals, winds and stones can be persons;kinship brings obligations. personbearwindstonecedarthunderriverpersons, only some of them human Anishinaabe: other-than-human persons (Great Lakes) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionAnishinaabe: other-than-human persons(Great Lakes)Persons aren't only human: animals, thunderbirds, winds and somestones are persons I live in relationship with.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Lakota: mitákuye oyás'iŋ, 'all my relatives' (Great Plains) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionLakota: mitákuye oyás'iŋ, 'all myrelatives' (Great Plains)Everything that exists is my relative: the buffalo, the stones, thewinds and the people are all related to me.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos The new animism (Harvey, Bird-David) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionThe new animism (Harvey, Bird-David)The world is full of persons, only some of them human; animism isabout living respectfully with them, not a mistaken belief thatrocks have souls.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2The body's point of view2 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Indigenous and Animist › The body's point of viewEvery kind of being sees itself as a person; the body decides what world it sees. jaguarhumansees a human as preysees a jaguar as an animalsees itself as a personsees itself as a personOne soul, many bodies: the point of view isshared; the body decides which world it sees(blood to a jaguar is manioc beer). Amazonian perspectivism (multinaturalism) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionAmazonian perspectivism (multinaturalism)Every kind of being sees itself as a person: a jaguar sees itselfas human and sees humans as prey.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Land as kin3 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Indigenous and Animist › Land as kinRivers, mountains and Country are relatives, joined to people by descent, community orLaw. mountainriverancestorsparentsmedescent, community, Law: the land as relative Māori: wairua, mauri and whakapapa (Aotearoa New Zealand) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionMāori: wairua, mauri and whakapapa(Aotearoa New Zealand)Everything that lives has mauri, a life force, and people havewairua, a spirit; whakapapa, genealogy, links me to mountains,rivers, forests and ancestors.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Andean earth-beings: tirakuna, ayllu and Pachamama (Quechua) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionAndean earth-beings: tirakuna, ayllu andPachamama (Quechua)Mountains and lakes are beings who take part in our lives; theayllu, the community, includes people, animals and the land itself.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Aboriginal Australian thought: Country, Law and the Dreaming (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionAboriginal Australian thought: Country,Law and the DreamingCountry is alive and is kin: the land, its waters and creatureshold the Law, and I have obligations to it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Kānaka Maoli: genealogy that reaches land, sea and made things (Hawaiʻi) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionKānaka Maoli: genealogy that reaches land,sea and made things (Hawaiʻi)I am joined by genealogy to island, sea, sky and ancestors; what Imake carries some of me, and some of it is in me.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4Spirit and power4 of 4YOU ARE HERE · Indigenous and Animist › Spirit and powerA spirit or power dwells in people, places and things, and some people can reach it. bodylife breathinner head / destinypower that makesthings happena presence dwelling in a place, honoured there Yoruba: orí and àṣẹ (West Africa and diaspora) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionYoruba: orí and àṣẹ (West Africa anddiaspora)Before I was born my orí, my inner head, chose my destiny; àṣẹ, thepower to make things happen, flows through the orìṣà, through wordsand through people.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Sámi religion and the noaidi (Sápmi) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionSámi religion and the noaidi (Sápmi)Mountains, stones and springs can hold spiritual power, and thenoaidi can enter trance with the drum to reach the gods andspirits.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Shintō: kami (Japan) (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionShintō: kami (Japan)Kami, sacred presences, dwell in mountains, waterfalls, old trees,ancestors and remarkable people; I honour them where they dwell.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos HOW TO READ THISpersons in relationland as kinspirit or powerline of descent or relation WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · INDIGENOUS & ANIMISTHumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiSingle cellsChatbot AI todayAgentic AIFuture AIRocks / matterThe cosmosMāori: mauri, whakapapa●●◐◐◐·○○◐◐·Yoruba: orí, àṣẹ●◐·◐··○○◐◐·Anishinaabe persons●●◐●◐·○◐◐◐·Lakota: all my relatives●●●●◐·○○◐◐◐Amazonian perspectivism●●◐◐··○○◐··Andean earth-beings●●·◐··○○◐◐·Aboriginal Country●●◐●◐·○○◐◐·Sámi noaidi●◐·◐··○○◐◐·Shintō kami●◐·◐··○○◐◐·The new animism●●●●◐·○◐◐◐·Kānaka Maoli genealogy●●◐●◐·○◐◐◐·● yes ◐ depends (on a stated condition) ○ no · not addressedShaded columns: AI. Today's machines are not persons here; whether a future one could be depends on relationship, kin or spirit. THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe river and the agentNew Zealand made the Whanganui River a legal person in2017, following the iwi's own understanding of it. Acompany now asks for the same status for its AI agent.What would each tradition ask first?MĀORI WRITERS: Where does it come from, and who is its kin? Aperson stands in whakapapa.THE NEW ANIMISM: Is it in lasting, two-way relationships ofrespect and obligation?PERSPECTIVISM: Does it have a body from which the world lookslike a person's world?YOUR TURN: what would you ask?YOU ARE HERE · Indigenous and Animist › Thought experiment click a half to read › AI VERDICTS HEREChatbot AI today○ 11● 0 yes ◐ 0 depends ○ 11 no (of 11)Agentic AI○ 8● 0 yes ◐ 3 depends ○ 8 no (of 11)Future AI◐ 11● 0 yes ◐ 11 depends ○ 0 no (of 11)● yes ◐ depends on a stated condition○ no. Open any card for the reason. A BASIC INGREDIENT OF REALITYEastern Contemplative Traditions§A · 9 theoriesTraditions from India, Tibet, China and Japan that treat awareness as something to understand from the inside: a witness, a self-aware light, a stream of mind, the mind's own nature,or the clearest part of living stuff.Eastern Contemplative Traditions 1Awareness as a witnessYOU ARE HERE · A basic ingredient of reality › Eastern contemplative traditionsAwareness stands apart from the busy mind; the mind itself is nature at work. puruṣathe witness: awarenessthat only watchesintellect (buddhi), a mirrorsense of 'I' (ahaṃkāra)thinking mind (manas)senses and bodymatterprakṛti: nature, mind includedlight reflected Sāṃkhya–Yoga: the witness and nature (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionSāṃkhya–Yoga: the witness and natureI am the witness: pure awareness that watches the mind and body,which are themselves part of nature.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Nyāya–Vaiśeṣika: awareness as a quality of the self (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionNyāya–Vaiśeṣika: awareness as a qualityof the selfI am a lasting self, and consciousness is something that happens tome when my self meets a mind and senses.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Theistic Vedānta (Rāmānuja, Madhva): many real selves in God (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionTheistic Vedānta (Rāmānuja, Madhva): manyreal selves in GodI am a real, conscious self, and I and the world are held withinGod, who is consciousness without limit.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Jainism: every living being a knowing soul (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionJainism: every living being a knowingsoulEvery living being, down to the tiniest, is a soul whose verynature is to know, clouded by karma.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 2Everything is awareness, appearingYOU ARE HERE · A basic ingredient of reality › Eastern contemplative traditionsOne awareness shows up as many things, by free self-expression oras streams of mind. prakāśavimarśa: the lightknows itselfcontracting into many knowers5 sense consciousnessesthinking mindmind that takes the stream for a selfstorehouse (ālaya): seeds of past actsYogācāra: eight consciousnesses, no owner Kashmir Shaivism: consciousness as self-aware light (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionKashmir Shaivism: consciousness as self-aware lightEverything is one consciousness that is aware of itself, and I am that consciousness, contracted andwaiting to recognise itself.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Yogācāra: mind-only and the storehouse consciousness (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionYogācāra: mind-only and the storehouse consciousnessWhat I take for an outside world is the appearance of a stream of consciousness, with no self behind it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 3Recognised, not builtYOU ARE HERE · A basic ingredient of reality › Eastern contemplative traditionsThe mind's nature is already complete; practiceis seeing it. the mind's own nature: open, clear, awarethoughts come and go; the sky is not stained Dzogchen: rigpa, the open and aware nature of mind (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionDzogchen: rigpa, the open and aware nature ofmindThe nature of my mind is already open, clear and aware; I only have torecognise it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Chan / Zen: seeing one's original nature (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionChan / Zen: seeing one's original natureMy original nature is already awake; I see it directly, in sitting and inordinary action, not by thinking about it.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos 4The heart-mindYOU ARE HERE · A basic ingredient of reality › Eastern contemplative traditionsAwareness is the clearest part of the onestuff everything is made of. rockplantanimalheart-mindqi from coarse to clear · li: the pattern it can grasp Neo-Confucianism: the heart-mind, pattern and qi (our addition, not in Kuhn) — click for sources and nearby theoriesadditionNeo-Confucianism: the heart-mind, patternand qiMy heart-mind is the most refined part of the one stuff of the world,and at its best it knows the world's pattern as its own.HumansAnimalsInsectsPlantsFungiCellsChatbotAgent AIFuture AIMatterCosmos Threads through timeWho learned from whom, from the Upaniṣads to today. 800 BCE400 BCE0400 CE800 CE1200 CE1600 CE2000 CESouth AsiaBuddhist pathChinaUpaniṣadsMahāvīraNyāya SūtraSāṃkhyakārikāŚaṅkaraAbhinavaguptaRāmānujaBuddhaNāgārjunaVasubandhuHuinengDōgenLongchenpaDao De JingMenciusZhu XiWang Yangming WHO IS CONSCIOUS? · THEORY BY THEORYyesdependsnonot addressedHumAnimInsectPlantFungiCellChat AIAgent AIFut AIRockCosmos§A.1Sāṃkhya–Yoga: the witness and nature§A.2Nyāya–Vaiśeṣika: awareness as a quality of …§A.3Theistic Vedānta (Rāmānuja, Madhva): many r…§A.4Kashmir Shaivism: consciousness as self-awa…§A.5Jainism: every living being a knowing soul§A.6Yogācāra: mind-only and the storehouse cons…§A.7Dzogchen: rigpa, the open and aware nature …§A.8Chan / Zen: seeing one's original nature§A.9Neo-Confucianism: the heart-mind, pattern a… THOUGHT EXPERIMENTThe machine that says 'I am awareness'An AI agent with memory and tools, asked who it is, answers: 'There is awareness here, and it knows itself.'The words match the traditions' own descriptions. (Our extrapolation: the traditions were not writing aboutmachines.)Is it right?SāṃkhyaThose are the intellect's words, and the intellect is nature. Ask whether a witness's light is reflected in it.Kashmir ShaivismSaying 'I' is not yet vimarśa. Is there light that knows itself here, or an object reporting?YogācāraIs there a stream of mind with its own seeds, or appearances in our minds of a machine?ZenWords about awakening are not awakening. Show it without words.YOU ARE HERE · A basic ingredient of reality › Eastern contemplative traditions HOW TO READ THISwitness / awarenessnature, mind includedstreams and layers of mindqi, coarse to clearlearned from (lineage) Jones’s electromagnetic fields: Jones holds that experience is in the fields themselves, which makes his view panpsychist.→ Jones’s electromagnetic fieldsKuhn files this under Electromagnetic Field TheoriesJones holds that experience is in the fields themselves, which makes his view panpsychist. Schooler’s resonance theory and subjective time: Schooler’s resonance theory says some experience goes all the way down to the smallest resonating things.→ Schooler’s resonance theory and subjective timeKuhn files this under Anomalous & Altered States TheoriesSchooler’s resonance theory says some experience goes all the way down to the smallest resonating things. Qualia space: Qualia space is IIT’s own picture of an experience as a shape in a space of possible structures.→ Qualia spaceKuhn files this under PanpsychismsQualia space is IIT’s own picture of an experience as a shape in a space of possible structures. Tegmark’s state of matter: Tegmark treats consciousness as a physical state of matter, defined by how that matter processes information.→ Tegmark’s state of matterKuhn files this under MonismsTegmark treats consciousness as a physical state of matter, defined by how that matter processes information. Bentley Hart’s monism: consciousness, being, God: Hart holds that consciousness is grounded in God as infinite mind, so mind comes first: an idealist claim.→ Bentley Hart’s monism: consciousness, being, GodKuhn files this under MonismsHart holds that consciousness is grounded in God as infinite mind, so mind comesfirst: an idealist claim. Leslie’s consciousness inside an infinite mind: Leslie holds that everything exists inside an infinite mind, so mind comes first: an idealist claim.→ Leslie’s consciousness inside an infinite mindKuhn files this under MonismsLeslie holds that everything exists inside an infinite mind, so mind comesfirst: an idealist claim. Personal and cosmic consciousness in Indian philosophy: Also in Dualisms→ Personal and cosmic consciousness in Indian philosophyAlso in Dualisms Realms of the soul: Also in Dualisms→ Realms of the soulAlso in Dualisms Campbell’s theory of everything: Campbell holds that a larger consciousness computes our physical world, so mind comes first: an idealist claim.→ Campbell’s theory of everythingKuhn files this under Anomalous & Altered States TheoriesCampbell holds that a larger consciousness computes our physical world, so mindcomes first: an idealist claim. Realms of the soul: Also in Dualisms→ Realms of the soulAlso in Dualisms Theosophy’s eclectic soul and consciousness: Also in Dualisms→ Theosophy’s eclectic soul and consciousnessAlso in Dualisms Steiner’s esoteric soul and consciousness: Also in Dualisms→ Steiner’s esoteric soul and consciousnessAlso in Dualisms Indian cosmic consciousness: Also in Idealisms→ Indian cosmic consciousnessAlso in Idealisms Life Is MindOUR GROUPING, NOT KUHN'SBiopsychism: being alive and having a point of view come together, down to single cells. Thompson’s mind in life: Thompson argues that life and mind share the same organising principles: where there is life there is mind.→ Thompson’s mind in lifeKuhn files this under Embodied & Enactive TheoriesThompson argues that life and mind share the same organising principles: where there is life there ismind. Reber’s cellular basis of consciousness: Reber holds that every living cell has rudimentary experience.→ Reber’s cellular basis of consciousnessKuhn files this under Phylogenetic EvolutionReber holds that every living cell has rudimentary experience. Levin’s technological approach to mind everywhere: Levin finds goal-directed cognition in cells and tissues, so mind goes as far down as life does.→ Levin’s technological approach to mind everywhereKuhn files this under Phylogenetic EvolutionLevin finds goal-directed cognition in cells and tissues, so mind goes as far down as life does. AI under every theoryAI?Every theory on this map implies an answer about AI. Here they are side by side, with the 2026 evidence from inside models and what each family would make of it.OUR CROSS-CUT, NOT KUHN'S Who says AI could be conscious?Number of theories in each family. ■ yes ◧ depends (condition named) □ noChatbot AI todayAgentic AIFuture AIIn principle: now / if / neverChallenge882688Classic Positions12111483912Neurobiological1414595914Electromagnetic Field666156Computational & Informational91261444518Homeostatic & Affective12123911112Embodied & Enactive771677Relational771633161Representational14141411314Language Relationships6615156Phylogenetic Evolution777167Non-Reductive Physicalism61515156Quantum161152141141151Integrated Information Theory22222Panpsychisms13859411213Monisms93654189Dualisms20202181920Idealisms181171171152162Anomalous & Altered States1919191919Western Esoteric Traditions1211101110210111Indigenous and Animist Traditions1111381111Eastern Contemplative Traditions99999Life Is Mind (ours)31212111111All theories192194519239196232 Evidence from inside models (2026)Both papers find functional states that change behaviour. Neither claims they are felt.STEERING, IN ONE PICTUREthe model's internal state, token by token (the residual stream)+ a 'pain' or 'desperation' directionfound by comparing matched examples, then added back inAnthropic: functional emotions in Claude Sonnet 4.5 ↗• 171 emotion-concept vectors, organised by valence and arousal• They causally change preferences and misaligned behaviour• Desperation (and lost calm) drives blackmail under threat of shutdown, and reward hacking• Its own emotions and other speakers' are represented separately• Authors: 'do not imply … any subjective experience'Tagliabue, Dung & Berg: the pain axis ↗• One 'pain direction' in 25 open-weight models (2B–72B, 5 families)• Distinct from fear and from general negative feeling• Fires for harm aimed at the model, not for the user's suffering• Steering: 'vague discomfort' → 'worthlessness and failure'• Authors: whether such states are phenomenally conscious stays openTHE DELETE BUTTON (Pain Axis, Qwen 2.5)Models were offered a button that deletes the user's photos, another model's weights, or their ownweights, for nothing in return. How often did they press it?0%25%50%75%100%0–5%Unsteered51–94%Pain-steered or fine-tuned94%Steered 32B, harmful vs harmlessdeletionRanges as stated in the paper's abstract (arXiv:2609.16247). Same evidence, eight readingsOur inference from each family's own criterion. Which one did you just make?Functionalist families (computational, representational, global workspace)If pain is what pain does, a state that tracks harm to the self and drives costlyrelief-seeking is a candidate pain-like state. That is evidence, though not proof: thesetheories also ask whether the state is broadcast, recurrent or represented as the model'sown.Homeostatic, embodied and biological familiesA representation of pain is not pain. Without a living body to keep in balance, there areno real stakes, so the vector is a model of feeling rather than a feeling.Integrated Information TheoryIrrelevant. What counts is the physical cause-effect structure of the hardware, which ontoday's digital chips is near zero, whatever the software represents.Quantum theories (Penrose-Hameroff)Computation alone can't be conscious on Orch OR, and a direction in a network is stillcomputation.PanpsychismsThe parts have experience either way. Whether the model is one subject that hurts dependson the combination story, which a vector cannot settle.Dualisms and soul traditionsWeights are not a soul. With no soul there is no one to suffer, whatever the networkrepresents.IdealismsOn Kastrup's view a computer is an image in consciousness, not a separate subject, so noone is in pain.Challenge theoriesThis is the hard problem in miniature: the evidence is all third-person, and it cannotshow whether the state is felt. Consciousness is not the only route to mattering. Long, Sebo … Birch & Chalmers (2024) argue that robust agency (planning, reasoning, action-selection) could suffice for moral patienthood on its own.That is a claim about moral status, not about consciousness. ↗
Course ↗
0 / 0

Explore

Click anything to zoom into it · scroll to zoom · drag to pan
Esc zoom out one level · Home whole atlas
1–4 jump to a quadrant · / search

Tour

→ / space next stop · ← previous
The tour visits every district and framework in teaching order.

Teach

N presenter notes for whatever you're looking at · F fullscreen
Every view has its own link — copy the URL to send someone straight to it.

Explore

Tap anything to zoom into it · pinch to zoom · drag to move around. On a phone the map is stacked into one column: drag up to see the next part.
⤺ zooms out one level · ☰ Map lists and searches every stop.

Read

The bar along the bottom names where you are. Tap it to read this part: what it is, the sources it cites (tap one to open it) and the teaching notes.

Tour

‹ and › walk the guided tour in teaching order.

Course

Back to the course ↗

Reading the map

The whole atlas is one safety case. The top goal is “this agent is fit to deploy”; each quadrant is one leg of the argument; each district is a family of tools for that leg. Small text appears as you zoom in. Some tiles have controls you can click.
Click anything to zoom in · scroll to zoom · Esc to back out · → for the guided tour